Foden’s Form Under Scrutiny After Stellar Season
Just 48 hours following Phil Foden’s historic performance for Manchester City, the midfielder appeared at the exclusive Mottram Hall, seemingly content and exuding a self-assurance that had been less evident before.
This confidence was rightly placed. Manager Pep Guardiola had spoken highly of the academy product, stating, “Phil took the team on his shoulders,” after a season where Foden dominated the Premier League. His campaign culminated in a brace against West Ham on the final day, including a signature strike that chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak had reportedly predicted in training.
A Season of 개인 Achievement
Foden’s previous season was undeniably one of individual brilliance. He himself felt he had truly arrived on the global stage, confidently discussing England’s attacking prospects for the European Championship and his own role in it. He had heard Guardiola draw parallels between his game-winning ability and Lionel Messi’s – a comparison made as he rode the momentum of 18 goals since the year began.
Unprecedented Midfield Performance
Remarkably, since his birth in 2000, no other midfielder in Europe’s top leagues had surpassed Foden’s 28 non-penalty goals in a single year for club and country. This put him ahead of legendary midfielders like Lampard, De Bruyne, Kaka, Ballack, Gerrard, and Toure.

vCard.red is a free platform for creating a mobile-friendly digital business cards. You can easily create a vCard and generate a QR code for it, allowing others to scan and save your contact details instantly.
The platform allows you to display contact information, social media links, services, and products all in one shareable link. Optional features include appointment scheduling, WhatsApp-based storefronts, media galleries, and custom design options.
Recalling this period highlights both Foden’s exceptional talent and how easily it can be overlooked amid Manchester City’s inconsistent season and, more recently, his subdued performance for England at Wembley.
International Form and Doubts
This subdued international form is not a new development. His prior European Championship campaign was unremarkable, with consistent starts but limited impact. “Maybe I came up short,” he recently admitted, acknowledging his underperformance.
Phil Foden’s recent England performance has raised concerns
His Euro 2024 campaign failed to live up to expectations
Mental fatigue reportedly impacted Foden’s early season form
Post-Euro Struggles and Mental Fatigue
Indeed, his Euro performance fell short, and its effects seemed to linger. Despite a minimal break, Foden surprisingly featured in Guardiola’s squad for the season opener against Chelsea, playing 45 minutes. However, he then disappeared from the team for almost a month due to an unexplained illness.
The 24-year-old has since disclosed experiencing “mental fatigue” at the season’s outset, describing a “foggy” mental state during training. It is also understood he faced a physical issue. Manchester City provides psychologist David Young as a resource for players when needed.
Speculation and Criticism
Both Manchester City and Foden’s representatives have declined to clarify the specifics of these issues. This lack of transparency creates a void where explanations for his diminished performances are absent, and online criticism – which Foden is known to follow – is escalating.
Concerns Among City Teammates
Reports indicate that Foden’s City teammates have privately expressed concern. He relocated his family to an area near Northwich, away from Manchester, seeking tranquility by a lake. Observers noted he appeared to have lost weight.
Tuchel’s Perspective and Future Role
Following England’s victory over Albania, manager Thomas Tuchel suggested Foden requires encouragement, alluding to a player whose once-evident confidence had waned. With Tuchel under pressure to deliver results and unable to carry underperforming players, Foden’s place in the starting lineup is no longer guaranteed.
Positioning and Impact
Foden is also believed to have felt some frustration with his role during the Euros, deployed on the left flank to accommodate Jude Bellingham. However, for a player who professes versatility and the ability to influence games from any position, it seems he must continue to perform effectively outside his preferred number 10 role.
Statistical Output vs. Perceived Form
Ironically, Foden’s statistical output this season is comparable to his previous year at City. He ranks second to Erling Haaland in goal contributions with 15, and leads in key passes completed. This suggests a broader team struggle, as Foden’s current season is considered a decline, yet no teammate has consistently stepped up to assume the level of responsibility he displayed last term.
Visible Dip in Confidence
However, simply observing Foden’s demeanor during matches reveals a different story.
Foden appears isolated and subdued during games
Concerns have been raised about Foden’s well-being
A return to form for Foden remains anticipated
Signs of Struggle on the Pitch
Foden seems isolated on the periphery. Six of his seven league goals came in a concentrated spell of four consecutive matches in January. Moments where he appears to be regaining his form are often followed by a retreat into a less impactful style. His carries into the penalty area and attempted dribbles have both decreased.
Spotlight on Foden’s Form
He is not alone in experiencing dips in form within the team. However, as Kevin De Bruyne’s assumed heir, and the reigning FWA and PFA Player of the Year, Foden inevitably faces heightened scrutiny.
Past Form Slumps and Heavy Workload
This is not Foden’s first period of inconsistent form. Manager Guardiola has consistently emphasized that such fluctuations are normal in a player’s career. This current dip follows a season where Foden accumulated 4,276 minutes for Manchester City alone (only slightly less than Rodri), and an additional 712 minutes across the European Championship and a friendly.
Exceeding Playing Time and Need for Rest
In total, Foden’s previous campaign extended to 4,988 minutes, surpassing even Rodri’s workload. Rodri has notably missed a significant portion of the current season due to an ACL injury, while Foden has continued to play.
Uncertainty About Future and Recovery
Foden likely needs a period of rest. Whether this will be possible, with the Club World Cup approaching and both Manchester City and England entering new phases, remains uncertain.
Anticipating Foden’s Return to Form
What remains clear is that Phil Foden possesses the talent and determination to rediscover his best form. The timeline for this return, however, currently remains unclear.