Should killer robots be banned? UN urged to prevent AI killers from violating human rights

Bonnie Docherty, a lecturer in law at Harvard University, fears the proliferation of weaponised Artificial Intelligence (AI) could be at odds with the international Convention on Conventional Weapons.

Together with the Human Rights Watch campaign group and the Harvard Law School International Human Rights Clinic, Ms Docherty has called on world governments to ban the development of so-called killer robots.

The call to stop autonomous weapons from being deployed in the battlefield comes days before representatives of more than 70 nations address the issue at a United Nations (UN) gathering in Geneva.

The topic of killer robots will be discussed next week between Monday, August 27, and Friday, August 31, by the signatories of the aforementioned convention.

In an article penned for The Conversation, Ms Docherty argued smart weapon systems, need to be banned because they cannot follow the simple principle of humanity and conscience.

vCard QR Code

vCard.red is a free platform for creating a mobile-friendly digital business cards. You can easily create a vCard and generate a QR code for it, allowing others to scan and save your contact details instantly.

The platform allows you to display contact information, social media links, services, and products all in one shareable link. Optional features include appointment scheduling, WhatsApp-based storefronts, media galleries, and custom design options.

She wrote: “Fully autonomous weapons, sometimes called ‘killer robots’, would select and engage targets without meaningful human control.

“They would be a dangerous step beyond current armed drones because there would be no human in the loop to determine when to fire and at what target.

“Although fully autonomous weapons do not yet exist, , Israel, Russia, South Korea, the United Kingdom and the United States are all working to develop them.

Killer Robots: Autonomous killing weapons

Killer robots: A campaigner has urged the United Nations to ban autonomous weapons (Image: GETTY)

“They argue that the technology would process information faster and keep soldiers off the battlefield.”

The so-called Martens Clause introduced at the 1899 Hague Convention dictates a baseline set of rules for safeguarding civilians and soldiers when a specific law treaty is absent.

Autonomous killing machines would no abide by the clause, Ms Docherty argued, because they lack the human element needed to asses combat situations.

The law expert added “delegating life-and-death decisions” into the hands of robots would be a clear violation of core human values.

She said: “We urge countries at this UN meeting to work toward a new treaty that would save people from lethal attacks made without human judgment or compassion.

We urge countries at this UN meeting to work toward a new treaty

Bonnie Docherty, Harvard University

“A clear ban on fully autonomous weapons would reinforce the longstanding moral and legal foundations of international humanitarian law articulated in the Martens Clause.”

As of April 2018, a total of 26 nations have so far backed calls to ban killer robots, according to campaign group Stop Killer Robots.

One of the nations backing this campaign is China, which stated it has called for a ban on the use of fully automated weapons.

Killer robots: Autonomous weapon system

Killer robots: Autonomous weapons would not follow the rules and laws of combat (Image: GETTY)

But not everyone agrees with this world-view and there are some who support the development of lethal autonomous machines.

The proponents of killer robot technology claims banning such weaponry would stifle the potential benefits it could bring to the table.

The is one such nation which has in 2012 published a Department of Defense Directive on the “responsibilities for the development of autonomous and semi-autonomous functions in weapon systems”.

The document established a set of guidelines to minimise the risk of smart weapons failing and engaging with unintended targets.

Killer robots: Terminator robot with gun

Killer robots: Some countries like the USA have published directives on the issue (Image: GETTY)

Autonomous weapons are described in the document as any “weapon system that, once activated, can select and engage targets without further intervention by a human operator.”

Under these rules, autonomous weapons also include any human-supervised weapon systems that can be overridden by human operators.

Peter Asaro, an associate professor of media studies at the New School, argued in April this year reaching consensus on the issue could be tricky because it is unprecedented.

He said: “Positive and meaningful action on this issue is still within reach, and it is up to the diplomats at the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons and their governments to prove that they can work together to address the full range of threats to humanity posed by autonomous weapons.”


🕐 Top News in the Last Hour By Importance Score

# Title 📊 i-Score
1 America's autism hotspots revealed as new data lays bare 'rampant epidemic' 🟢 85 / 100
2 Piers Morgan and JK Rowling lead celebs praising new UK law on sex and gender 🔴 78 / 100
3 Putin’s play for an Indonesian airbase was always likely to fail – but Russia has wider ambitions 🔴 75 / 100
4 US to hold talks on Ukraine with Europeans 🔴 75 / 100
5 Fake Ozempic drugs found in US drug supply, FDA warns 🔴 75 / 100
6 What should I do with a property in the French Alps in my divorce? HEATHER ROGERS replies 🔴 65 / 100
7 Zoom restores service after an hours-long outage 🔴 65 / 100
8 The Who drummer Zak Starkey breaks silence after he’s kicked out of band after almost 30 years 🔵 45 / 100
9 Add one type of exercise to your weight loss plan to burn more calories 🔵 45 / 100
10 AFL coach Luke Beveridge drops bombshell about the future of troubled footy star Jamarra Ugle-Hagan after greats of the game called for him to be axed over wild social media videos 🔵 45 / 100

View More Top News ➡️