Importance Score: 4 / 100 🟠
The Return, now available on Paramount+, is a captivating interpretation of Homer’s Odyssey, potentially overlooked in film history. Ralph Fiennes delivers a compelling performance as the battle-worn Odysseus, journeying back to Ithaca after two decades to confront the suitors besieging his wife Penelope, portrayed by Juliette Binoche. This marks their first collaboration since The English Patient. Despite director Uberto Pasolini’s commendable efforts, the film’s release was overshadowed by the announcement of Christopher Nolan’s anticipated epic adaptation of the Odyssey, slated for 2026. Coming shortly after Fiennes’ lauded performance in Conclave further diverted attention. This noteworthy film deserves recognition, and here’s why it’s worth watching.
The Return: Stream or Skip?
The Gist: Ralph Fiennes’ dedication to his role is evident in his physical preparation. His Odysseus is rugged and formidable. He embodies the hardened warrior returning from the Trojan War and his encounters with mythical creatures. Odysseus arrives on the shores of Ithaca, weary after his long journey, encountered by his former swineherd Eumaes (Claudio Santamaria), who does not recognize him. Odysseus has been transformed by his experiences. Eumaes shelters him, unaware of his true identity.
Meanwhile, Penelope (Juliette Binoche) navigates complex palace intrigue. Her demeanor reflects both her enduring love for Odysseus and her growing resentment over his prolonged absence. Her home is besieged by suitors vying for her hand, whom she rebuffs by claiming she will choose one when she finishes weaving a shroud for Odysseus’ father, yet she delays its completion each night. Their son, Telemachus (Charlie Plummer), bears no memory of his father and distrusts his mother. The power vacuum in Ithaca places both Penelope and Telemachus at risk.
Odysseus’ disguise proves beneficial in this treacherous environment. Strikingly, this adaptation omits the intervention of gods and goddesses. Instead, the narrative focuses on human actions and consequences. A poignant moment occurs when Odysseus’ loyal dog recognizes him and subsequently dies. Posing as a beggar, Odysseus strategically reveals his identity to select individuals he trusts. He reconnects with Telemachus, who was an infant when he departed, and cautiously approaches Penelope, whose intuition remains sharp. The tension builds as Odysseus prepares to reclaim his place.
Similar Movies
What Movies Will It Remind You Of?: Consider Fiennes’ own directorial work, Coriolanus, combined with the historical accuracy of The Northman—although not quite as detailed—and the familial conflicts of The Lion in Winter. This blend captures the essence of The Return.
vCard.red is a free platform for creating a mobile-friendly digital business cards. You can easily create a vCard and generate a QR code for it, allowing others to scan and save your contact details instantly.
The platform allows you to display contact information, social media links, services, and products all in one shareable link. Optional features include appointment scheduling, WhatsApp-based storefronts, media galleries, and custom design options.
Outstanding Performance
Performance Worth Watching: Fiennes demonstrates his talent for classical roles. Beyond his performances in Wes Anderson films or as Voldemort, he remains a top actor in the industry.
Memorable Dialogue
Memorable Dialogue: Odysseus encapsulates the impact of war with the line: “For some, war becomes home.”
Sex and Nudity
Sex and Skin: The film features full-frontal nudity of Ralph Fiennes, as well as scenes involving Penelope’s female servants interacting with the suitors.
Critical Analysis
Our Take: Pasolini’s dedication to historical precision and realistic portrayal of classical myths enlivens The Return. Fiennes and Binoche deliver outstanding performances. Their shared scenes are rich with unspoken implications, as the two navigate their complex relationship as characters who understand some truths while being unsure of others. These glances portray seeking, knowing, and searching. Their performances are both engaging and profound.
Setting aside earlier considerations, The Return warrants consideration as profound exploration of marriage and commitment. While Homer may have intended Odysseus and Penelope’s story as a romance, Pasolini, alongside co-writers John Collee and Edward Bond, portrays it as an look at long-term love and commitment. While a 20-year absence tests modern sensibilities, the suitors are far from appealing, rendering Odysseus’ actions understandable, especially given his honorable nature. Not to mention, his exceptional physical condition.
Beneath the surface lie insights into what war signifies to both men and women, and insights on how it bestows power. Pasolini frames the inevitable violence as condemnation, like Clint Eastwood’s approach in Unforgiven. The Return offers viewers a new perspective on a well-known story, making it compelling.
Our Call: A must-see. STREAM IT.