Importance Score: 65 / 100 🔴
Fan Demand Actress Replacement in Upcoming Beatles Biopics
Enthusiasts anticipating the forthcoming biographical films about The Beatles are advocating for a cast alteration, specifically urging for one actress to assume a role within the highly anticipated productions. A diverse response greeted the recent cast announcement for the quartet of Beatles movies, scheduled for release in 2028, with numerous individuals suggesting a particular star should embody one of the iconic musicians.
Casting Choices Spark Fan Reactions
The biopics are slated to feature Paul Mescal, Harris Dickinson, Barry Keoghan, and Joseph Quinn, taking on the roles of Paul McCartney, John Lennon, Ringo Starr, and George Harrison, respectively. However, a segment of the audience, expressing reservations regarding the casting choices, has voiced a desire for an actress to step in, donning a wig to portray one of The Beatles.
Jodie Comer: A Unconventional Casting Suggestion
Notably, some fervent supporters have gone further, proposing that the actress in question should not only embody one Beatle, but rather undertake the ambitious endeavor of portraying all four members of the band, superseding the officially announced cast.
Social Media Fuels Casting Debate
Online platforms have become epicenters for this casting discourse. One user questioned, “Why couldn’t they let Jodie Comer play all four Beatles?” Echoing this sentiment, another user enthusiastically added, “The idea of Jodie Comer in drag playing all four Beatles in all four biopics.”
Inspiration from Cate Blanchett’s Bob Dylan Portrayal
Drawing parallels with acclaimed performances, a third user posted, “Need Jodie Comer to pull a Cate Blanchett as Bob Dylan and play a Beatle.” This alludes to Blanchett’s widely lauded depiction of the legendary songwriter Bob Dylan in the 2007 film I’m Not There. That film uniquely featured multiple actors, including Christian Bale, Heath Ledger, and Richard Gere, in the role of Dylan.
Comer’s Liverpudlian Roots and Beatles Admiration
Proponents of Comer’s casting argue that she could “easily play Paul [McCartney]” and highlight her Liverpudlian heritage as lending a more authentic connection to the band’s origins compared to the current ensemble cast. Furthermore, in a past interview alongside Austin Butler, Comer openly declared The Beatles as the “greatest band of all time,” further fueling fan campaigns for her involvement. Some admirers have even envisioned Comer tackling all four Beatles roles akin to her acclaimed one-woman show, Prima Facie.
“Prima Facie” Style Beatles Biopic?
Expanding on this concept, fans have suggested: “For those four new Sam Mendes Beatles films they should cast Jodie Comer to play all four but in a Prima Facie style one women show.”
Director Sam Mendes and Ringo Starr Respond
Sam Mendes, the director helming all four biopics, has articulated his deep connection to the band, stating, “The Beatles changed my understanding of music. I’ve been trying to make a movie about them for years. We’re not just making one film about the Beatles – we’re making four. Perhaps this is a chance to understand them a little more deeply.”
Beatles drummer Ringo Starr has offered his perspective on the ambitious undertaking, characterizing the plan to produce four films as “madness.” He elaborated, mentioning the interconnected nature of the projects: “madness of making four movies at the same time … there’ll be Beatles in mine around when I joined, and there’ll be Beatles in Paul’s. We’ll all be there.”
Positive Reactions to Initial Casting
Conversely, not all reactions have been critical. Many express satisfaction with the announced cast, with one user remarking, “Stop complaining about the casting for The Beatles biopic. I think they look great.”
Adding to the positive sentiment, another user commented, “Seen a lot of moaning about the Beatles film cast. It’s not a lookalike competition! As long as there is some resemblance and can act the part I’m happy. That, a good script, interesting idea and quality director are what’s really needed for a great biopic.”