That delectable biscuit, airy potato snack, or delicate white bread share a common trait: an irresistible, yielding texture.
The Texture Factor: How Soft Foods May Contribute to Overeating
But does texture truly matter? Research into ultra-processed foods (UPFs), frequently associated with weight gain and health issues, suggests that their appealing texture could be a primary concern, potentially overshadowing the impact of low fiber and nutrient deficiencies.
Understanding Ultra-Processed Foods (UPFs)
Generally, UPFs are heavily processed food items that contain additives and components not typically found in home cooking. They often contain high levels of calories, salt, sugar, and fat.
The Science of Satiety and Food Texture
When food enters the stomach, it expands, triggering the release of hormones that signal fullness to the brain. However, these signals require time to travel throughout the body.
The theory proposes that the easy-to-chew and rapidly consumed nature of UPFs can lead to excessive consumption before the body’s satiety signals can effectively register. In essence, the brain’s “full” message arrives too late.
vCard.red is a free platform for creating a mobile-friendly digital business cards. You can easily create a vCard and generate a QR code for it, allowing others to scan and save your contact details instantly.
The platform allows you to display contact information, social media links, services, and products all in one shareable link. Optional features include appointment scheduling, WhatsApp-based storefronts, media galleries, and custom design options.
Consequently, faster eating accelerates consumption and increases the likelihood of overeating. While occasional indulgence poses no significant issue, frequent overeating can result in consuming more calories than the body requires.
Landmark Study Highlights Overeating with UPFs
A significant study published in Cell Metabolism in 2019 provided key insights into the link between UPFs and overeating. The research indicated that participants consumed an average of 500 additional calories daily on a UPF diet compared to an unprocessed diet.
In this study, 20 participants were assigned either a diet rich in ultra-processed foods or a diet of unprocessed foods. Both diets were carefully matched for calorie content, sugar, fat, and fiber, and participants were allowed to eat as much or as little as they desired.
Dr Emily Leeming, microbiome scientist, registered dietitian, and chef
The group consuming UPFs gained nearly one kilogram within a mere two weeks, while the unprocessed food group experienced a similar amount of weight loss.
Interestingly, taste was not the driving factor. Participants didn’t express greater enjoyment of UPFs, but they did consume them at twice the speed.
Texture Matters Beyond Processing
However, soft texture isn’t exclusive to UPFs. Minimally processed soft foods, like apple purée, are also consumed at a significantly faster rate than their raw counterparts, such as whole apples.
A 2022 study in The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition corroborated this, concluding that softer foods, regardless of processing level, lead to increased consumption simply due to quicker chewing and swallowing.
Further supporting this, a 2023 study in the European Journal of Nutrition demonstrated that food hardness or softness has a greater impact on consumption volume than processing level.
This study revealed that participants consumed 33% more food and 85% faster when meals were soft – processing level had no discernible effect.
The Texture Effect Extends to Beverages
This principle extends to drinks as well. A 2008 study in the International Journal of Obesity found that individuals consumed considerably more thin chocolate milk compared to thicker, custard-like versions—approximately 30% more, amounting to an extra 243 calories.
Thicker beverages require more time to consume, promoting quicker feelings of fullness and thus reducing overall intake.
Softer foods are less satiating and easier to chew, delaying the brain’s fullness signals compared to bulkier, unprocessed foods
Why Softer Foods Lead to Overconsumption
One explanation for the delayed feedback mechanism to the brain with UPFs is that softer foods are less satiating – they occupy less space in the stomach.
Conversely, bulkier foods stretch the stomach, effectively signaling satiety.
Not All Soft Foods Are Problematic
It’s crucial to note that not all soft foods should be avoided. Many, such as Greek yogurt and mashed sweet potatoes, are nutrient-rich and valuable components of a balanced diet.
Soft textures can also be beneficial for individuals with chewing difficulties, such as older adults, ensuring adequate nutrition with reduced choking risk.
However, when selecting calorie-dense, nutrient-poor options, considering texture becomes pertinent.
Beyond texture, other factors can contribute to overeating. Here are some strategies to consider:
Strategies to Promote Mindful Eating
Minimize Distractions During Meals
Eating while distracted can lead to increased consumption without conscious awareness.
A 2013 review and meta-analysis in The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition revealed that distracted eaters consumed approximately 10% more food during the meal and around 25% more at subsequent meals, due to a lack of focus on satiety cues.
Practice Mindful Eating
Conversely, paying attention to the sensory aspects of food – taste, texture, and aroma – can result in approximately 10% less consumption at later meals.
This benefit may stem from improved memory of the meal, enhancing the effectiveness of the body’s fullness signals.
Tips for Mindful Eating
- Eliminate screen use during meals.
- Take smaller bites.
- Focus on the flavors and textures of each mouthful.
These practices allow the body sufficient time to recognize satiety.
Optimize Cutlery Choices for Portion Control
Smaller Cutlery at Home
Utilizing smaller cutlery at home can subtly reduce food intake.
A 2018 study in the British Journal of Nutrition found that using a smaller spoon encouraged smaller bites and slower eating, leading to roughly 8% less overall consumption.
Smaller bites provide the body more time to register fullness.
Larger Cutlery When Dining Out
Interestingly, research suggests context matters.
While smaller cutlery may aid portion control at home, a 2012 study in the Journal of Consumer Research suggests larger cutlery in busy restaurant settings could promote satiety and prevent overeating.
Researchers found that in restaurants, heightened eating motivation combined with smaller cutlery created a perception of insufficient progress, paradoxically leading to increased consumption.
Therefore, consider using smaller forks or spoons for portion control at home, but opt for larger cutlery when dining out to avoid rapid overconsumption.
Emphasize Thorough Chewing
The Benefits of Chewing Food More
“Chew your food properly and don’t rush” is common parental advice that holds true for adults as well. Increased chewing can effectively reduce food intake.
A 2014 study in the Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics indicated that increasing chewing duration by 150% to 200% – approximately 42 to 56 chews per mouthful – resulted in up to 14% less food consumption.
Slower chewing also extends meal duration, allowing the body ample time to release satiety hormones without increasing subsequent hunger.
Practical Chewing Technique
To implement this strategy, count your chews for several bites at each meal and aim to double that count.
This simple adjustment may promote earlier satiety and facilitate natural portion control.