Dreaming of a Caribbean getaway but wary of tourist traps?
Travel expert Tanneka Fleary from Golden Grenadine Travel reveals which overcrowded destinations to avoid and recommends superior alternatives for an authentic island experience.
Fleary cautions, “Tourist traps are often characterized by large crowds, inflated prices, and a disconnect from the genuine local culture and environment.”
“These locations can negatively impact both travelers and host countries by contributing to the exploitation of natural resources and local communities.”

vCard.red is a free platform for creating a mobile-friendly digital business cards. You can easily create a vCard and generate a QR code for it, allowing others to scan and save your contact details instantly.
The platform allows you to display contact information, social media links, services, and products all in one shareable link. Optional features include appointment scheduling, WhatsApp-based storefronts, media galleries, and custom design options.
She emphasizes, “The aim is to sustainably enjoy a destination, experiencing its true essence rather than fabricated tourist attractions.”
Discover the crowded locales to bypass and serene havens offering pristine natural beauty.
Where to Avoid and Alternative Destinations
Opt for Reach Falls Over Dunn’s River Falls in Jamaica
Dunn’s River Falls in Jamaica is a beautiful location but frequently congested with tourists, diminishing the experience, according to Tanneka Fleary of Golden Grenadine Travel.
Reach Falls, Jamaica, offers a more tranquil and serene alternative to the bustling Dunn’s River Falls, suggests Fleary.
Dunn’s River Falls, near Ocho Rios, Jamaica, is a celebrated cascade, yet Fleary notes it is “often overcrowded with tourists.”
The influx of visitors “makes it challenging to fully appreciate the inherent splendor of the falls,” the travel specialist elaborates.
Fleary advises, “Consider Reach Falls instead. This more tranquil option is situated in eastern Jamaica.”
“Nestled within a verdant rainforest, Reach Falls provides a peaceful sanctuary featuring crystal-clear natural pools, ideal for swimming and enjoying the undisturbed beauty of the surroundings.”
Choose Exuma Over Nassau in The Bahamas
Nassau is a significant Bahamian travel hub, receiving millions of cruise passengers annually.
However, Fleary points out that the sheer volume of tourists creates an “overwhelming atmosphere at the busy cruise port, with constant tourist traffic.”
She states, “The area is heavily trafficked and lacks the authentic allure many travelers seek.”
Fleary observes that the crowds in Nassau, Bahamas, contribute to an overwhelming cruise port experience, detracting from authentic island charm.
Exuma, comprised of over 365 islands and cays in The Bahamas, is recommended by Fleary as an alternative, offering “a true slice of paradise.”
Where should travelers venture instead?
Fleary recommends Exuma, encompassing 365 islands and cays, describing it as “a true slice of paradise.”
The travel authority adds, “Eco-conscious visitors will value its dedication to preserving natural beauty. Moreover, opportunities abound to swim with pigs on select islands.”
Skip Gros Islet Street Party for Marigot Bay in St Lucia
The Gros Islet Street Party in St Lucia, held every Friday, is a well-known tourist attraction. However, Fleary suggests the party’s “chaotic ambiance” can be “more stressful than relaxing.”
She suggests the serene Marigot Bay on St Lucia’s western coast as a “more relaxed and peaceful alternative.”
The travel expert describes Marigot Bay: “Renowned for its placid waters and picturesque vistas, it is a haven for sailing, kayaking, or unwinding. Eco-luxury resorts dot the bay, fostering a tranquil setting perfect for immersing oneself in nature and genuine local culture, away from the tourist bustle.”
Avoid Maho Beach, Choose Pinel Island in Saint Martin
Maho Beach in Saint Martin can be “overwhelming due to excessive crowds and noise,” according to Fleary.
Pinel Island is suggested by Fleary as a replacement for Maho Beach, known for its “pristine beaches, calm waters, and superb snorkeling.”
The Dutch side of Saint Martin is a favored cruise destination, and Maho Beach is particularly famous for aircraft landing nearby.
Yet, for those less interested in aviation, it may be best avoided. Fleary clarifies that “the experience can be overwhelming due to crowds and noise.”
The travel advisor proposes Pinel Island, located off the French coast of Saint Martin, as a preferable option.
Fleary remarks, “Pinel Island, with its immaculate shores, tranquil seas, and excellent snorkeling, is the perfect peaceful escape.”
“The island also features charming local eateries serving fresh seafood, providing an authentic taste of island living.”
Little Cayman: A Better Choice Than Grand Cayman
Seven Mile Beach, a celebrated stretch of golden sand on Grand Cayman’s western shore, is famed for its beauty.
However, Fleary indicates its popularity also renders it one of the island’s most “overcrowded locations.”
Seven Mile Beach’s widespread acclaim contributes to it being among Grand Cayman’s most congested areas.
Little Cayman is lauded by Fleary for its “incredible natural beauty” and tranquil ambiance.
She recommends Little Cayman, the smallest of the Cayman Islands, as a “less developed, less crowded hidden treasure.”
Fleary reveals, “It boasts remarkable natural beauty and some of the Caribbean’s finest diving destinations.”
She highlights the island’s wildlife and “pristine beaches.”
The travel expert concludes, “[It offers] a relaxed atmosphere, providing a welcome respite from heavily touristed zones.”