The loosely defined region of the North Atlantic Ocean has been at the centre of bizarre events both on water and in the air dating back to 1492, when Christopher Columbus and the Santa Maria crew reported a sighting of unknown light, just days before the landing at Guanahani. The vicinity of this so-called triangle is among the most heavily travelled shipping lanes in the world, with vessels frequently crossing through it for ports in the Americas, Europe and the Caribbean islands. Popular culture has attributed various disappearances to the paranormal or even some kind of colossal sea monster, but researchers discovered the true fate of the SS Cotopaxi, which disappeared without a trace in 1925, carrying a cargo of coal and a crew of 32.
About 35 years ago, divers came across a shipwreck off the coast of St Augustine called “Bear Wreck” and for the past few decades, diver Michael Barnette and his team have been exploring the wreck – which they now believe is the remains of the SS Cotopaxi.
Mr Barnette took measurements of the shipwreck, looked at historical newspaper articles and insurance records, and examined artefacts found at the wreck.
He said in January: “The Cotopaxi was really the only option.
“It’s the one that just kind of screamed out.”
The group’s underwater quest was featured in the February 9 premiere of the Science Channel’s “Shipwreck Secrets” series.
Mr Barnette, a marine biologist at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), added: “It was incredibly exciting.
“I’ve done a countless number of shipwreck dives but this one truly stood out.”
To further verify his findings, Mr Barnette consulted researchers at a Smithsonian affiliate St Augustine Lighthouse & Maritime Museum.
READ MORE: ‘Cursed’ ship found completely intact 90 years after sinking
Wooden hatch covers for the ship’s cargo holds were in disrepair, allowing water from rough weather to slosh below deck, Mr Barnette’s research showed.
He added: “The ship was doomed at that point.”
Caught by a massive storm, the crew “had no shelter” and the situation went from “bad to catastrophic in very short order,” according to Mr Barnette.
In a final nail into the coffin of the Bermuda Triangle theory, Mr Barnette said the site of the Cotopaxi wreckage would likely fall outside its loose borders – just like many other wrecks associated with the conspiracy.