Mexico City Says Ex-Government Altered Data to Hide Crime Rate

(Bloomberg) — Mexico City’s government has been under attack by critics who say violence has spun out of control since a new, left-leaning administration took over in late 2018.

Run by Mayor Claudia Sheinbaum since December, the city now says that the previous administration extensively under-reported crime. As a result, while it appears that the crime rate has shot up in 2019 under new leadership, by some measures it’s actually fallen.

Reviews of tens of thousands of criminal files from 2018 show the city’s homicides haven’t risen this year by more than a third, as previously reported, but by only about 12%, said Ernestina Godoy, Mexico City’s chief prosecutor. Violent crimes as a whole have dropped by 8% this year, she said.

The new figures, which will be released as part of official federal data on Saturday, are bound to raise questions about how trustworthy any government’s crime statistics are in Mexico. President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador won election in a landslide a year ago on promises to crack down on rampant corruption and violence. Sheinbaum, Mexico City’s first elected female mayor, is a member of his party and a close ally.

Registry ‘Distorted’

Godoy says United Nations officials oversaw the process of reclassifying the criminal cases.

“The registry was distorted,” Godoy said in an interview at her office. “In cases of rape they were classified as sexual harassment or abuse, or just injuries.”

Out of 214,000 files reviewed from 2018, more than 24,000 so-called “high-impact” criminal cases had been doctored, she said. Rape last year had actually been double the number reported by the administration of Miguel Angel Mancera, mayor since 2012.

A spokeswoman for Mancera, now a senator, said he was traveling and couldn’t immediately comment. He denied the allegations when they were first made by Godoy in January in more general terms.

Official data currently shows murders in Mexico’s capital city jumped 36% during January to May compared with the same period a year ago. Godoy says homicides will now formally be registered as having risen by about 12% in January-June from a year ago.

That’s still far too many, Godoy added. “This is not being done to justify our government,” she said. “We won’t deny the situation we are in.”

To contact the reporter on this story: Nacha Cattan in Mexico City at [email protected]

To contact the editors responsible for this story: Juan Pablo Spinetto at [email protected], Ros Krasny, Ian Fisher

For more articles like this, please visit us at

©2019 Bloomberg L.P.