Importance Score: 70 / 100 🔴
First Look at JFK Jr. and Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy in “American Love Story” Sparks Debate
Ryan Murphy, the celebrated creator of “American Horror Story,” is facing a divided response to the initial images of the actors portraying John F. Kennedy Jr. and Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy in his forthcoming anthology series, “American Love Story.” The series aims to recount the iconic romance, but casting and costume choices have ignited discussions among viewers.
Murphy Shares First Images on Instagram
Murphy, 59, unveiled the first glimpse of Paul Kelly (as JFK Jr.) and Sarah Pidgeon (as Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy) on Instagram over the weekend. The post, dated Saturday, June 14, included stills from a camera test. “We started shooting this week in New York City and can’t wait until you see the romantic and tragic love story between America’s prince, JFK Jr., and fashion icon Carolyn Bessette,” Murphy conveyed.
Fan Reactions: Casting Decisions Under Scrutiny
Despite Murphy’s enthusiasm, the debut visuals of “American Love Story” have drawn mixed reactions. Some viewers have openly criticized the choices made in casting and the accuracy of the wardrobe, as observed in the initial images.
LONZERUI2024 New Mens Smart Watch with a 420Mah Large Battery, 1.96-Inch Ultra HD Screen, Wireless Calling, Flashlight Feature,, Suitable for Android And Ios Outdoor Use
Price: $0.62
Mens Gothic Hoodie - Fashion Hoodies with Retro Lace Up Design, Casual Graphic Print, Streetwear Style for Winter Fall, Great Gift Idea
Price: $1.79
[Anti-Slip Basketball Shoes] Anti-Slip Durable Mens High-Top Basketball Shoes | Fashion Training Sneakers for Sports and Casual Wear
🎉 Exclusive deal [Price: $9.19]
Criticism of Casting and Costume Design
The online response included:
- Skepticism regarding the casting of Sarah Pidgeon as Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy, with one commenter questioning, “There was nobody else who could play Carolyn?!”
- Concerns over costume authenticity, exemplified by comments on Pidgeon’s attire: “She would never wear this,” with reference to a leather overcoat, black sweater, trousers, and pointed-toe heels ensemble.
- Remarks about hair styling, with a fan noting, “Her blonde hair is all wrong… It should be warmer. Not platinum. Please try again.”
Differing Views on the Portrayal of JFK Jr.
Paul Kelly’s portrayal of JFK Jr. also faced scrutiny:
- Comparisons to the real-life figure, with one critic stating, “JFK Jr was gorgeous, this guy is average.”
- General disappointment expressed by some viewers: “Usually the actors are better looking than the real people… Both are not good looking enough as the real people. How sad!”
- Strong opinions suggesting the project should be reconsidered: “I think maybe Ryan Murphy should be stopped,” and “Ryan needs to take a break, seriously.”
Positive Responses to the “American Love Story” Casting
Conversely, a segment of viewers lauded Kelly and Pidgeon’s casting, praising them as suitable choices for the roles of the political figure and the fashion icon.
- Supportive comments on Murphy’s post included observations like “Casting looks great”
- Some noted the likeness: “Wow, I knew who they were before even reading the caption.”
Background on JFK Jr. and Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy’s Relationship
First announced in 2021, the project’s focus on John F. Kennedy Jr. and Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy’s relationship was revealed in September 2024. The couple initially met in 1992 when Bessette, then working for Calvin Klein, guided Kennedy Jr. through a fitting.
Tragic End to a Prominent Couple
The pair wed in September 1996 but their lives tragically ended three years later. In July 1999, JFK Jr., Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy, and her sister Lauren Bessette perished in a plane crash off the coast of Massachusetts.
“American Love Story” Cast
Besides Kelly and Pidgeon, the series features Naomi Watts as Jackie Kennedy, Grace Gummer as Caroline Kennedy, Sydney Lemmon as Lauren Bessette, and Alessandro Nivola as Calvin Klein. “American Love Story” is anticipated to explore the nuances of their relationship against the backdrop of American society.