Importance Score: 78 / 100 🔴
SAO PAULO — The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) advocates for an enduring oversight mechanism to observe Brazil’s adherence to recommendations outlined following the destructive flooding in southern Brazil, which occurred one year ago.
IACHR Calls for Continuous Surveillance
Javier Palummo, the IACHR’s special envoy, discussed the proposed initiative with The Associated Press. The aim is to establish a sustainable communication link with Brazil’s authorities and “enhance public responsibility, highlight successful practices globally, and oversee potential regressions—especially in the hardest-hit regions and among susceptible populations.”
Impact of Southern Brazil Floods
Between April and May 2024, catastrophic floods struck nearly every locality in the southern state of Rio Grande do Sul. More than 2.3 million individuals were impacted. Hundreds of thousands were uprooted, and 182 fatalities were confirmed, according to official records. The extent of the damage was likened by experts to the devastation caused by Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans in 2005.
Challenges in Recovery
A recent IACHR report, published Wednesday, underscores the stark disparities in the recovery endeavor. Indigenous and quilombola communities—home to descendants of enslaved people, female-led households, and those without shelter—have encountered substantial difficulties in obtaining assistance for rehabilitation and accessing public amenities.
Barriers Faced by Vulnerable Communities
“These communities often reported being marginalized in reconstruction planning,” Palummo stated. “Inadequate land administration and insufficient institutional involvement perpetuate historical injustices.”
- Lack of land registration in quilombola communities
- Limited engagement from local and federal agencies
- Persistent racial disparities and neglect of indigenous communities
Notable Observations from the Field
During a December visit to inundated areas, Palummo praised the resiliency of a quilombola community where women spearheaded relief efforts. He also noted the plight of the Mbyá-Guarani people of Eldorado do Sul. Their homes and school, destroyed first by flooding and then by construction, forced them to relocate near a major roadway, exposing them to risks and cultural loss.
Structural Inequalities and Climate Vulnerability
“These catastrophes are not solely natural disasters—they are exacerbated by persistent neglect,” he asserted. “They reflect deep-rooted structural inequalities and escalating climate susceptibility, driven by unplanned urban development, environmental deterioration, and environmental discrimination.”
Upcoming Presentations and Discussions
According to Palummo, the report is the first of its kind by the commission, an affiliate of the Organization of American States (OAS). He will present the findings next week to local communities in Porto Alegre and to federal and state dignitaries. Palummo is also scheduled to address a public hearing on May 8 in Brasília.
Find additional coverage on Latin America and the Caribbean through our comprehensive coverage.