Importance Score: 45 / 100 🔵
Quentin Tarantino Singles Out a Film as His Weakest
Director Quentin Tarantino has identified one of his movies as the least accomplished of his career, suggesting he would sooner retire than create another similar film. The movie in question, the 2007 release Death Proof, came during a period that Tarantino has openly criticized. He has often spoken about the late 1990s and 2000s, describing it as an era of excessive production where quality decreased in pursuit of quantity.
Tarantino’s Critique of Overproduction in Cinema
According to the filmmaker, that time resulted in numerous studio-supported endeavors that leaned too cautiously into safety or experimented heavily, arguing this atmosphere may have impacted both the public perception of his film and his current assessment of it.
Director’s Roundtable Remarks
During a 2012 discussion with fellow directors, Tarantino commented, “Death Proof has got to be the worst movie I ever made. If that’s the worst I ever get, I’m good.”
“Death Proof” and the “Grindhouse” Experiment
Death Proof, launched in 2007 as part of a double feature—a collaborative project with Robert Rodriguez called Grindhouse—centers on a stuntman who utilizes his “death-proof” vehicle to hunt and murder women. However, he ultimately encounters worthy adversaries in a group of resolute female characters.
Tarantino has stated that while the underlying concept retains merit, the ultimate execution fell short of his expectations, failing to connect with audiences as effectively as some of his other projects.
Initial Reception and Criticisms
Upon its release, Death Proof generated varied reactions. Certain viewers lauded its practical stunt work and homages to 1970s exploitation cinema. Conversely, it encountered censure due to its deliberate tempo, extensive dialogue segments, and divided narrative structure.
The movie occurs in two acts, each concentrating on distinct sets of women entangled with the core antagonist. Although the climactic sequence boasts an energizing car chase, widely appreciated as a highlight, earlier portions of the film failed to impress a number of viewers.
Impact of the “Grindhouse” Format
Tarantino has since posited that the less favorable reception partly stemmed from the structure inherent in the Grindhouse concept. Being one half of a double feature, his picture trailed Rodriguez’s Planet Terror, a high-octane zombie action film exhibiting a vastly dissimilar feel.
Such juxtaposition plausibly rendered Death Proof comparatively sluggish and talk-heavy, particularly for viewers anticipating relentless action.
Stylistic Choices and Nostalgia
From a stylistic standpoint, Death Proof consciously adopts a retro aesthetic, incorporating aged film stock effects, missing scenes, and various visual signals intended to replicate grindhouse cinema. While those traits sought to rekindle fondness for a precise period within filmmaking, they equally fueled claims that the final product leaned excessively on nostalgia as opposed to unique substance.
Rotten Tomatoes Score
- Death Proof holds a 66% score on Rotten Tomatoes
- Tarantino’s other films generally boast over 80% marks
- Exemption: The Hateful Eight scored 74%
Death Proof, unsurprisingly, has Tarantino’s lowest rating on the review aggregation website Rotten Tomatoes.