Alex Murdaugh’s defense attorney today exploded at the legal scion’s former law partner as he suggested he is only helping the prosecution because he is ‘angry’ about stolen money.
‘Do you think he did it?’ Dick Harpootlian boomed at Ronnie Crosby, who took the stand in the double murder trial this morning as a final rebuttal witness for the State.
‘I don’t have an opinion, I don’t have the benefit of the materials you have,’ Crosby replied.
The point-blank question concluded a furious exchange during which Harpootlian told Crosby he was only testifying against Murdaugh because he cheated their clients out of millions leading to the downfall of their firm.
Crosby railed against the claim, stating: ‘You are dead wrong if you think I’ve come in here and said something to this jury because of money when we’re talking about two people who were brutally murdered, then you are headed in the wrong direction.’
‘Do you think he did?’ Dick Harpootlian (left) boomed at Ronnie Crosby, who took the stand in the double murder trial this morning as a final rebuttal witness for the prosecution
Buster, Paul, Maggie and Alex Murdaugh on a family vacation in Lake Keowee in May 2021 – a month before the killings
Murdaugh stole more than $10m from clients and partners at the firm during a decade of embezzlement leading up to the murders of Maggie, 52, and Paul, 22, at the family’s hunting estate in Moselle, South Carolina, on the night of June 7, 2021.
The State claims he was motivated to kill the pair because his life was spiraling out of control and he was ‘out of time and out of options.’
On the day of the killings he was confronted over $792,000 that had gone ‘missing’ from a recent case. Over the next few months his colleagues would uncover the millions he stole, ultimately leading to him being fired.
Murdaugh says Maggie and Paul were killed by vigilantes in revenge for his son’s drunken boat crash two years before in which a 19-year-old girl was killed.
He claimed Paul had been threatened and attacked after the accident. Murdaugh was due in court the week of the murders for a hearing on financial disclosure in the boat case. He was being sued for up to $30m by the family of Mallory Beach who died in the wreck.
This morning, Crosby said to Harpootlian: ‘If you’re implying that I would somehow shade truth because of [Murdaugh’s financial crimes]. I would take high offence to that Mr Harpootlian.’
Harpootlian replied: ‘I’m not concerned about your high offence, are you angry about him stealing your money?’
Crosby said: ‘I have no feeling one way or the other.’
Harpootlian queried: ‘You don’t have any feeling about Alex Murdaugh deceiving you and stealing your money?’
Crosby admitted: ‘I have had anger with him Mr Harpootlian, extreme anger, Mr Harpootlian, because of what he did to my law firm, my partners, our clients, what he did to his family, what he’s done to so many people, yes I experienced a lot of anger.
‘But you can’t walk around with anger you have to find a way to deal with it and move forward and I have done that.’
Defendant Alex Murdaugh cries as the shooting injuries his family suffered are described in detail during his double murder trial at the Colleton County Courthouse, Tuesday
Ronnie Crosby, Hampton trial attorney and former law partner of Alex Murdaugh, right, is questioned by prosecutor Creighton Waters during Murdaugh’s double murder trial at the Colleton County Courthouse on Tuesday
Crosby testifies at the trial Tuesday as the prosecution called a series of rebuttal witnesses ahead of the jury being sent out to reach their verdict
Alex’s brother John Marvin Murdaugh, sister Lynn Murdaugh Goette, Brooklynn White, Buster Murdaugh’s girlfriend, and Buster listen to the evidence Tuesday
Maggie’s body was found a few yards to the right of a doghouse, while Paul’s was by the doorway at the end of the kennels. Judge Clifton Newman yesterday granted the defense request for jurors to visit the scene to gain a better understanding of the shootings
Prosecutor Creighton Waters said yesterday he planned on calling up to five reply witnesses who ‘will be focused on issues raised during the defense case.’
The defense earlier called the alleged killer’s younger brother as its 14th and final witness, wrapping up a week of testimony compared to the State’s four weeks of evidence to jurors.
John Marvin Murdaugh wept as he recalled cleaning up his nephew’s brains which were still splattered across the kennels at the hunting estate the day after the murders.
A crime scene expert for Murdaugh’s team testified that two killers were operating that night, arguing that the shotgun gunman would have been incapacitated after firing into Paul’s head at close range. Timothy Palmbach said the shooter would have been blinded by blood, and likely injured by fragments of skull or pellets.
The State says Murdaugh first blasted Paul, 22, twice with a 12-gauge shotgun before turning a .300 Blackout rifle on Maggie, 52, shooting her five times.
Following the prosecution’s reply witnesses, the jurors will make the half-hour trip from the Colleton County courthouse to the kennels at the estate after the judge granted a defense request to give them a better understanding of the scene.
Murdaugh’s defense attorney Dick Harpootlian warned the judge that cops need to close the road and secure the gates beforehand to stop the jury being influenced by the ‘carnival attitude’ of trial enthusiasts trespassing on the property.
Murdaugh arrives Tuesday with his blazer draped over his handcuffs after stepping out of the prison van
Paul, Maggie, Alex and Buster Murdaugh attend a dinner at the South Carolina Yacht Club. Buster was staying with his girlfriend outside Charlotte at the time of the killings
Harpootlian said Alex’s brother John Marvin was forced to call the sheriff last weekend because ‘literally dozens’ of trespassers were taking selfies in the feed room at the kennels where Paul was blasted twice with a shotgun.
Judge Newman said that a visit to the estate could be arranged – overruling the prosecution objection. He assured Harpootlian the scene would be secured.
The defense later called Timothy Palmbach, a crime scene expert, who told jurors that Paul suffered a ‘contact wound’ meaning the muzzle of the 12-gauge shotgun was touching the back of his head.
Palmbach explained that ‘the explosive release of the gas trapped in [Paul’s] cranium’ would have forced blood, tissue, brain matter, fragments of skull and shot pellets back out through the entry wound, covering the shooter.
He said this would have at the very least blinded the killer and possibly even caused injury, making the prosecution claim that Murdaugh recovered moments later to shoot Maggie with a different weapon implausible.
‘I think minimally that shooter is getting covered with this material and getting the shockwave of that and more than likely getting hit with at least something that is causing injury, a bone fragment or pellet fragment,’ Palmbach said.
Buster Murdaugh arrives with his girlfriend Brooklynn White and followed by Alex’s sister Lynn
Buster Murdaugh and his girlfriend Brooklynn White arrive with Alex’s sister Lynn and brother John Marvin on Tuesday
Alex Murdaugh smiles while talking with defense attorney Jim Griffin during his double murder trial at the Colleton County Courthouse in Walterboro on Monday
‘Therefore, I think the shooter is, at least for some brief period of time, kind of out of it. It’s not as if they can instantly suffer that, run to where the rifle is, pick that up and within any reasonable time period engage in an effective assault, shoot straight and make hits.’
He added: ‘I believe the individual who shot first, probably with blood in his eyes and maybe even injured, would have taken some degree of time to recover.’
Palmbach said that had there been only one shooter, this would have given Maggie time to run. But she was found just a few yards away from her son.
The expert said there was no reason for one killer using two firearms, especially given the high magazine capacity of a standard .300 Blackout rifle.
No murder weapon has ever been found.
The prosecution dispute Palmbach’s claim that Paul was shot in the back of the head and instead claim he was facing the shooter.
When cops arrived around 10pm, about an hour after Maggie and Paul were killed, Murdaugh was clean from head to toe in a white t-shirt, shorts and sneakers.
Murdaugh claims he went to visit his mother in Almeda, around 15 minutes away, and when he got back his wife and son were dead.
The State suggests at some point that evening he changed clothes. Murdaugh appeared in a video earlier that night taken by Paul wearing long pants, a dress shirt and loafers.
Murdaugh wept at the defense table as his brother described cleaning up his dead son’s brains that were still splattered across the feed room at the kennels the day after the killings
The kennels at the estate. Paul was shot in the feed room which stands at the far right end of the row of dog cages
Paul’s body was found lying in the doorway of the feed room at the end of the row of dog cages at the kennels. Prosecutors say Murdaugh first blasted Paul twice with a shotgun before killing his wife with a rifle a few moments later
Maggie’s blood-soaked body lies under a sheet at the crime scene on the night of June 7, 2021. She was shot five times with an assault rifle, while Paul was blasted twice with a shotgun a few yards away at the kennels on the estate
MURDER SCENE: Paul’s body lies outside the storage room, while Maggie lies just outside the kennels by the doghouse
The defense called John Marvin as its 14th and final witness Monday who wept as he described cleaning up Paul’s brains the day after the murders because ‘it felt like the right thing to do, I felt like I owed him.’.
John Marvin said he returned to the crime scene with police permission after arriving to be at Alex’s side on the night his wife and son were shot dead.
He said the grass where Maggie’s blood-soaked body had lain was covered with dirt ‘so there was really nothing to do.’ But the feed room at the kennels where Paul was blasted twice with a shotgun was still covered in blood and brain matter.
John Marvin sobbed as he described the scene, telling jurors: ‘I saw blood, I saw brains, I saw pieces of skull, I saw tissue – and when I say brains it could just be tissue – I don’t know what I saw, it was just terrible.
‘And for some reason I thought it was something that I needed to do for Paul to clean it up. It felt like it was the right thing to do, I felt like I owed him and I started cleaning.
‘I can promise you no mother or father or aunt or uncle should ever have to do and see what I did that day.
‘I’m not blaming anybody but I was just overwhelmed and I did everything I could and I would have moments where I would stop crying for a moment, just in disbelief.’
Murdaugh wept at the defense table as his brother described the horrifying ordeal.
John Marvin Murdaugh and his wife Liz outside the Colleton County courthouse Monday
Alex’s younger brother John Marvin with his wife Liz, and his older brother Randy with his wife Christy, arrive at court Monday
Buster Murdaugh, center, arrives with his girlfriend Brooklynn White, Alex’s sister Lynn (left) and brother John Marvin (right)
‘At one point I called my brother Randy and told him what I was doing and he immediately told me to stop doing it, it was not good for me and it was not healthy for me to be there,’ John Marvin said.
‘And I couldn’t stop. I had to do it for Paul. It’s just what I had to do.’
He said: ‘It was probably 15 or 20 minutes later, Mark Ball (a close family friend) shows up, y’all heard Mark Ball testify and came and hugged me and told me it was okay to leave. Okay to leave what was rest of Paul and that they would clean it up.’
He added: ‘It’s the hardest thing I’ve ever been through in my life.’
Murdaugh during the trial has floated his own theory of who committed the murders, testifying on Friday that he believed someone angry over a deadly boating accident involving Paul had done so.
He acknowledged that he lacked evidence to support that theory.
During his testimony, he also said he had deceived law partners and clients out of huge sums of money to feed his drug habit, potentially undercutting his credibility with the jury.
Murdaugh arrives surrounded by sheriffs at the courthouse Monday
Buster, Maggie, Paul and Alex Murdaugh in a photo the mother posted for Father’s Day in 2020
Under cross examination, Waters sought to portray Murdaugh as a serial liar who was under pressure due to mounting financial troubles in the months leading up to the killings.
Murdaugh admitted to lying to investigators in the aftermath of the murders by telling them he was not at the kennels on the night of the murders.
He changed his account after the jury saw cellphone video that contained audio of Murdaugh’s voice that placed him at the scene minutes before investigators have said his wife and son were killed.
Murdaugh, the scion of an influential South Carolina legal family, was indicted by a grand jury in July and pleaded not guilty to two counts of murder and two counts of possession of a weapon.
The case has drawn intense media coverage given the political influence of the Murdaugh family in South Carolina.
Murdaugh’s sole surviving son Buster, 26, has attended court everyday and testified last week. The disbarred attorney’s brothers John Marvin and Randy and sister Lynn have also attended the Colleton County courthouse in Walterboro most days.