Polls closed in Pennsylvania Tuesday after a dramatic primary season that pit former President Donald Trump against some of his closest political allies and featured the Senate Democratic winner spending election day in surgery.
Early returns showed Dave McCormick – the conservative candidate snubbed by Trump – taking an early lead in what’s become a three-way race between the hedge funder, television personality Dr. Mehmet Oz and commentator Kathy Barnette.
As the night went on, Oz got within striking distance of McCormick with around 2,000 votes between the two men.
On the Democratic side, Lt. Gov. John Fetterman won the Senate primary over rivals Rep. Conor Lamb and state Rep. Malcolm Kenyatta.
On Friday the 52-year-old Fetterman suffered a stroke, and had a pacemaker implanted on Tuesday, hours after he voted in the election by absentee ballot from Lancaster General Hospital.
The Trump-backed choice for GOP governor – state Sen. Doug Mastriano – won his race.
Mastriano made a name for himself by pushing the so-called ‘big lie,’ and had Trump election lawyer Jenna Ellis as a guest at his election night party.
Republican Senate candidate Dave McCormick – who was snubbed by former President Donald Trump – has been leading in the returns all night in a close race between him, Dr. Mehmet Oz and Kathy Barnette. He greets supporters at an event in Pittsburgh Tuesday night
Democratic Senate hopeful Lt. Gov. John Fetterman cast an absentee ballot from Lancaster General Hospital after suffering from a stroke Friday. On Tuesday doctors performed pacemaker surgery on the 52-year-old former Braddock mayor
Pennsylvania Republican Senate candidate Dr. Mehmet Oz and his wife Lisa Oz arrive to cast their vote, in Bryn Athyn, Pennsylvania, on Tuesday with the GOP primary set to go down to the wire
Gisele Fetterman (center right) watches election returns come in Tuesday night at an event in Imperial, Pennsylvania, outside of Pittsburgh. She headlined the election night fete as her husband Democratic Senate nominee John Fetterman remained in the hospital
The Trump-backed state Sen. Doug Mastriano pulled into the lead of the Republican primary for Pennsylvania governor Tuesday night. Some Republicans fear that Mastriano will be easily beat by Democrat Josh Shapiro over his peddlng of the ‘big lie’
Republican gubernatorial hopeful Doug Mastriano had Trump’s former election lawyer Jenna Ellis speak at his election night event Tuesday in Chambersburg, Pennsylvania. Ellis was also a vocal advocate of the ‘big lie’
The Democrats’ night wrapped up much more quickly than Pennsylvania’s Republicans.
Pennsylvania’s Attorney General Josh Shapiro, running unopposed for the Democratic nomination for governor, was called the winner of his race as soon as polls closed.
Shapiro, recovering from COVID-19, tweeted that he was ‘humbled and honored’ to be Democrats’ nominee.
‘No matter what dangerous extremist we’re against this November, the stakes are too damn high for anything but a victory,’ Shapiro said.
Fetterman, still hospitalized, made a quick video appearance at his election night event once the race was called for him at 8:54 p.m.
The event was headlined by his wife Gisele, who assured the crowd that ‘John is going to be back on his feet in no time.’
‘He is the bionic man now,’ she told CNN. ‘He’s feeling great. The surgery was perfect.’
President Joe Biden applauded Fetterman’s win in a statement Tuesday night, using it as an opportunity to call out the Republican candidates as ‘too dangerous, too craven, and too extreme.’
Gisele Fetterman, stumping for her husband while he remained hospitalized, talked to reporters outside her Braddock, Pennsylvania polling place on Tuesday
Republican candidate for a Pennsylvania U.S. Senate seat Dave McCormick (left) leaves his polling place in Pittsburgh with his wife Dina Powell (right)
Lt. Gov. John Fetterman’s supporters sign a ‘get well soon’ card for the Democrat, who won his party’s Pennsylvania Senate nomination Tuesday night
Supporters arrive at a primary election night gathering for Republican Senate hopeful Kathy Barnette in Elizabethtown, Pennsylvania
Dr. Mehmet Oz gives a thumbs up to a passing car outside a polling place Tuesday in Rockledge, Pennsylvania
State Sen. Doug Mastriano (right) alongside his wife Rebecca (left) celebrate his win in the GOP Pennsylvania gubernatorial primary at an event in Chambersburg, Pennsylvania
Mastriano’s race was called just before 10 p.m.
‘They like to call people who stand on the Constitution far right and extreme. I repudiate that, that is crap. That is absolutely not true,’ Mastriano told a crowd of supporters at his Chambersburg, Pennsylvania victory event.
He said the Democrats were ‘extreme’ due to their COVID policies, calling it a ‘dark time’ and blasting Admiral Rachel Levine, the Assistant Secretary for Health who formerly was Pennsylvania’s Secretary of Health.
‘And their darling, of course, would be promoted to admiral – woman of the year,’ he said of Levine, apparently mocking her for being transgender.
Mastriano pledged to do away with COVID mandates, jab-for-job requirements and critical race theory on day one.
‘This is infectious here because we all love freedom,’ Mastriano said.
The Cook Political Report moved the Pennsylvania governor’s race from toss-up to lean Democrat after Mastriano’s win, as his positions on 2020 election interference and abortion may not play well in the purple state.
Kathy Barnette, a Republican hopeful for U.S. Senate, was in third place through Tuesday night, following Dave McCormick and Dr. Mehmet Oz
REPUBLICAN SENATE PRIMARY
The race to replace retiring Republican Sen. Pat Toomey looked very different early on, with Trump wading in early and endorsing Sean Parnell, who tried to unseat Lamb in a Congressional race in 2020.
Trump endorsed Parnell in early September.
Less than three months later, Parnell was out, after a judge in the Republican’s child custody case found abuse claims made by his estranged wife to be credible.
In the months following, a number of Trump White House figures played adviser – official and unofficial – to McCormick, the former CEO of Bridgewater Associates who had been considered for several administration positions during the ex-president’s tenure
Politico reported in January that Trump White House alumni Hope Hicks and Stephen Miller were advising McCormick’s campaign, while other Trump insiders including Kellyanne Conway, Sarah Huckabee Sanders, Tony Sayegh and Larry Kudlow were advising the candidate unofficially.
McCormick’s wife, Dina Powell, served in the Trump administration.
But in April, Trump threw his weight behind Oz arguing that the TV doctor would ‘be the one most able to win the General Election,’ arguing that Oz could pull votes away from Democrats in Pennsylvania’s left-leaning cities of Pittsburgh and Philadelphia.
A number of conservatives cried foul, pointing out Oz’s less-than-steadfast positions on abortion, transgender rights and guns.
‘It’s like Donald Trump’s staff is sabotaging Trump by convincing him to make the worse possible endorsements,’ conservative pundit Erick Erickson complained on Twitter directly after the ex-president announced Oz as his pick.
As primary election day neared, Pennsylvania Republicans showed fresh interest in Barnette, a far-right candidate who said she was part of the pro-life movement because she was a byproduct at rape, arguing during a debate, ‘I’m still not just a lump of cells, my life has value.’
The comments came after conservative Justice Samuel Alito’s draft opinion to overturn Roe v. Wade was leaked.
‘I am so very grateful that our nation is having a very important conversation about life. I am the byproduct of a rape. My mother was 11-years-old when I was conceived, my father was twenty-one,’ Barnette said, using the anecdote to launch an attack on Oz, who previously shared pro-choice views.
Final polls showed Oz with a narrow lead.
An Emerson poll released Monday had Oz at 32 per cent, Barnette at 27 per cent and McCormick at 26 per cent.
Trump was pushing for Oz until the end.
Politico reported Monday that Trump recorded a call that went out to Pennsylvania voters knocking McCormick for being soft on China and hammering Barnette for wanting to erect a statue of former Democratic President Barack Obama, a Trump nemesis.
Politifact rated claims about Barnette wanting to erect a statue of Obama ‘mostly true,’ as she pushed for statues of the Obama family and Frederick Douglass to be added to the Emancipation Memorial – which shows President Abraham Lincoln standing over a slave – which was targeted for removal during the 2020 wave of racial justice protests in the aftermath of the death of George Floyd.
On Monday, NBC News reported on a newly surfaced photograph that appeared to show Kathy Barnette (circled) marching toward the U.S. Capitol Building on January 6
Another image that reportedly shows Republican Senate hopeful Kathy Barnette (circled) marching toward the U.S. Capitol Building with members of the Proud Boys and other Trump supporters on January 6
Barnette, who is black, said she never supported or voted for Obama, but explained that the slave in the controversial statue would be ‘looking into the future of where this nation will be’ by facing an additional statue of the Obama family.
Republicans aligned with her rivals have also pointed to problematic statements Barnette has made about Muslims and homosexuality.
Additionally on Monday, Barnette was identified in a newly surfaced photograph marching toward the Capitol Building on January 6.
Barnette’s team denied she took part in or condoned any violent behavior in comments to NBC.
‘Kathy was in DC to support President Trump and demand election accountability. Any assertion that she participated in or supported the destruction of property is intentionally false. She has no connection whatsoever to the proud boys,’ her staff said in a statement.
Democrat Josh Shapiro, Pennsylvania’s attorney general, won the primary unopposed in the Democratic gubernatorial primary, while Republican state Sen. Doug Mastriano (right) won his gubernatorial primary after being endorsed by former President Donald Trump
PENNSYLVANIA GUBERNATORIAL PRIMARY
On Saturday, Trump officially endorsed GOP gubernatorial hopeful Mastriano, who was also in Washington on January 6.
‘There is no one in Pennsylvania who has done more, or fought harder, for Election Integrity than State Senator Doug Mastriano,’ Trump wrote. ‘He has revealed the Deceit, Corruption, and outright Theft of the 2020 Presidential Election, and will do something about it.’
Mastriano, a state senator and retired U.S. Army colonel, was one of the loudest voices echoing Trump’s false claims of losing the 2020 election due to widespread voter fraud – including in the Keystone State, which Trump won in 2016 only to lose to President Joe Biden four years later.
Mastriano was about even in polling with former Rep. Lou Barletta, also seeking to replace the term-limited Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf, until mid-April and then he began to surge.
Beyond embracing the so-called ‘big lie’ and being present in D.C. on January 6, Mastriano said he didn’t believe there should be any exceptions for women seeking abortions, even in cases of rape, incest or potential death.
Some Pennsylvania Republicans are worried that Mastriano’s positions are too extreme for the swing state.
And on the Democratic side of his race, Shapiro, the state’s current attorney general, won his race unopposed.
Rep. Conor Lamb (center left), holding son Matthew and wife Hayley (left), arrive at a polling location Tuesday in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Democratic Pennsylvania Senate hopeful, Lt. Gov. John Fetterman, said Sunday that he suffered a stroke on Friday, just days before voters head to the polls. His campaign also said Monday that he would remain hospitalized through election day
Democratic Senate hopeful Malcolm Kenyatta (left) greets Pennsylvania’s current Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf in the Old City neighborhood of Philadelphia. Kenyatta, who represents part of Philly in the state House, has trailed ‘yinzers’ John Fetterman and Conor Lamb
DEMOCRATIC SENATE PRIMARY
National Democrats believe that the party’s best chance to flip a Republican Senate seat is likely in Pennsylvania.
The Democratic primary pit two Pittsburgh-area Democrats against one who represents part of Philadelphia.
Fetterman, who’s been the state’s lieutenant governor since 2019, was formerly the mayor of Braddock, a steel town that hugs the Monongahela River just outside of Pittsburgh.
The six-foot-nine inch politician is known for wearing gym shorts, supported Bernie Sanders’ campaign and regularly trolls Republicans at Pennsylvania’s capitol in Harrisburg by flying rainbow and marijuana flags outside his office displaying his support for LGBTQ+ rights and more liberal drug policies.
A Franklin & Marshall poll from late April showed Fetterman a comfortable 39 points ahead of Lamb, who’s also from the Pittsburgh area.
The six-foot-nine Lt. Gov. John Fetterman has been leading in the Democratic Pennsylvania Senate primary polls. Fetterman is known for wearing gym shorts, supporting Bernie Sanders and flying marijuana flags outside the Pennsylvania state capitol
Rep. Conor Lamb, who like Fetterman is from the Pittsburgh area, has argued that he’s a Democrat who can win in Trump-friendly areas, as he did in his partially rural district in a special election against a Trump-backed Republican in 2018
Lamb promoted himself as a candidate who could win in a year when Democrats expect a shellacking – pointing to his March 2018 special election win in a partially rural district hugging Pittsburgh over a Trump-aligned Republican.
Coming in third in the polls was Kenyatta, a gay, black Pennsylvania state House member, who’s the grandson of civil rights organizer Muhammad Kenyatta.
Fetterman’s eleventh hour admission that he had a stroke didn’t seem to impact the race.
In a statement released Sunday, Fetterman said that doctors told him ‘I didn’t suffer any cognitive damage’ from the stroke.
‘I’m well on my way to a full recovery,’ he noted.
But on Monday his campaign said that he wouldn’t be at his election night event, with his wife Gisele – who’s been a dynamic presence on the campaign trail – slated to speak instead.
THE TRUMP FACTOR
In the Republican primaries so far, Trump has a mixed record.
His Ohio Senate pick – Hillbilly Elegy author J.D. Vance – won his primary.
But last Tuesday, Trump’s pick for Nebraska governor, Charles Herbster, lost the Republican primary to Jim Pillen, a hog farmer and University of Nebraska Regent who had the support of the state’s outgoing Republican Gov. Pete Ricketts.
Herbster had been plagued with serial groping allegations from at least eight women in the run-up to election day, with Trump backing him anyway.
Trump’s chosen candidate in a West Virginia Republican House primary did win last Tuesday.
Rep. Alexander Mooney easily beat Rep. David McKinley in a race that pit two sitting congressman against each other due to West Virginia losing a House seat in reapportionment.
Mooney had Trump’s support, while McKinley was endorsed by the state’s Republican Gov. Jim Justice.
On Tuesday night, Trump’s potency will also be on the ballot in North Carolina, as the scandal-plagued but Trump-backed Rep. Madison Cawthorn fights off a primary challenge.