Chicago Public Schools remained closed on Thursday and lessons may not resume for its 350,000 students until Monday after the teachers’ union and city failed to come to an agreement on additional COVID-19 policies.
Thursday marked the second day of what city and public school officials called an ‘illegal strike’ by the Chicago Teachers Union, which announced at 11pm on Tuesday its members would refuse in-person learning until the district implements its demands.
The CTU, led by socialist Jesse Sharkey, wants an opt-out COVID testing regime that would see pupils tested without parental consent.
This goes much further than the New York City and Los Angeles School Districts, the two largest in the nation, that require opt-in.
Mayor Lori Lightfoot hit out at the proposal last night: ‘You’re not going to be in a world where we do a quasi medical procedure on little children without their parents affirmative, written consent.
‘We are not going to flip the switch and take from parents the ability to determine for their own family, whether or not there’s going to be testing.’
The CTU is also demanding that the city and Chicago Public Schools ask students to provide a negative COVID test in order to come back to in-person classes and schools to go remote if 20 per cent of staff were in isolation or in quarantine.
Lightfoot has refused these demands that collectively go further than rules imposed in New York City and Los Angeles School Districts, where schools are open.
The Chicago Teachers Union, which protested outside City Hall, failed to reach an agreement with the city on Wednesday night, keeping city schools closed on Thursday
The CTU, led by socialist Jesse Sharkey (left), made demands that all students be tested for COVID-19 before schools can reopen. Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot and school leaders said they would not give into the CTU’s demands
Chicago Public Schools CEO Pedro Martinez said he had no choice but to cancel schools on Thursday and called it a losing day for teachers and parents.
‘For me, it’s a day of mourning,’ Martinez said in a statement.
‘I’m sad for how, as a district, we are responding to parents…because parents are losing in this process.’
While the union voted for remote working, there is no such system in place, remote devices have not been handed out, and therefore Chicago’s 350,000 students did not receive tuition today.
Martinez and Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot have said they would not give into the demands made by the CTU, which is among the most radical in the nation.
Lightfoot and school leaders assured parents and teachers that schools have been thoroughly cleaned and disinfected.
The city also beefed up its substitute staff, and the city has stacked up on millions of testing kits which it will prioritize on symptomatic and unvaccinated students, who would likely cause additional spread.
Masks have also been provided to all staff and students, new ventilation systems and HEPA filters have been installed in school buildings, and social distancing policies are still in effect.
The upgrades were met to combat the COVID Omicron surge and keep schools open as city and school officials recognized the failings of remote-learning.
It also came as Chicago Public Health Commissioner Dr. Allison Arwady said COVID was now no worse than the flu and that kids were actually safer in school than being out and about in the city.
But the CTU continues to reject the city’s compromises.
‘There are so many things we could partner on,’ Lightfoot said on Wednesday. ‘Instead, they chose an illegal, unilateral action that throws the whole system into chaos and makes us a laughingstock all across the country.’
Chicago Alderman Raymond Lopez, who has chided the mayor on everything from public safety to emergency powers, told Politico that the CTU will likely never give in until all their demands are met.
‘They are on a mission to be obstructionists to this administration in a way that puts me to shame. I can recognize when she does something right, and they refuse to do even that.’
The demands from CTU are the most extreme in the nation and do not match what has been advocated by the larger New York City and Los Angeles teachers unions.
New York City did away with its policy of quarantining entire classrooms exposed to COVID-19 in hopes of keeping more kids in school.
In order to combat Omicron, the school instead opted to ramp up its testing on staff and students who were symptomatic and unvaccinated through its ‘Stay Safe and Stay Open’ policy.
The city also engages in random surveillance testing to disrupt any asymptomatic spreads.
The Los Angeles School district, the second largest in the nation, however, has ordered that all students and staff submit negative COVID-19 tests by Sunday in order to safely resume classes next week.
But the district has joined the powerful California Teachers Association in pledging to keep schools open despite the Omicron surge after the state secured millions of testing kits for students.
Chicago Public Schools could be reopened by Friday on a case-by-case scenario depending on how many active COVID cases there are and how many staff members were in quarantine.
Lightfoot said teachers who are called in to work on Friday but fail to show up will have their pay docked.
School districts nationwide have grappled with the same issue, with most opting to stay open while ramping up virus testing, tweaking protocols and making other real-time adjustments in response to the shifting pandemic.
Many Chicago public school students live on or below the poverty line, with analysis repeatedly showing poorer children are most likely to fall behind with remote learning.
Meanwhile, CDC data shows just 803 children aged 0 to 18 have been killed by COVID since the start of the pandemic in the US.
As of Wednesday night, 9,000 students and 2,300 staff members were either in isolation or quarantine because they came in close contact with someone with COVID.
About 91% of Chicago teachers are fully vaccinated and half of students aged 12 and older.
The Chicago closure came after parents slammed the socialist leader of the Chicago Teachers Union after he today defended the last minute decision to shutter schools by claiming ‘going in puts students and families at risk.’
Chicago Teachers Union President Jesse Sharkey held a Zoom press conference on Wednesday to defend the union’s vote to cancel in person classes at 11pm Tuesday and move to remote learning over COVID fears.
Sharkey said: ‘Right now going into schools puts us at risk, puts our students and families at risk. We’re in the middle of a dangerous surge. We don’t think bars should be open.’
He claimed that the city’s safety plan to return to in-person learning was ‘fairly inadequate.’
Just 400 positive COVID cases were reported Tuesday morning, with about 70% students and 30% staff.
There are 350,000 pupils in Chicago schools.
Parents were quick to criticize Sharkey and the union.
‘You’re using our children as leverage. Parents are the ones to decide if it’s safe to send our children to school. This is a disgraceful power move,’ one said on Twitter in response to his press conference.
‘If I got to vote to stay home in my warm house you bet your ass I would,’ another said.
‘Every single one of the teachers who don’t show for in class teaching should immediately be fired,’ quipped another.
‘So if you’re a fully vaccinated and boosted teacher, and wear a mask all day, it’s not safe to go to work? Just tying to understand for the all teachers outside of Chicago that are back at school. Can you scientifically describe your risk vs outside the City’s border?’ another asked.
President Trump slammed the teachers too, saying: ‘What is happening in Chicago with all the school closures is devastating.
‘Democrats are congregating en masse tomorrow to fan the flames of a divide that THEY created, while our kids sit at home watching their futures vanish. It must stop.
‘Educate our children in person or give every dollar spent on education directly to the students so they can get out of these failing government schools!
The union’s late night decision on Tuesday to close schools caused utter chaos for parents on Wednesday.
Mayor Lori Lightfoot warned that teachers who failed to turn up would be docked pay after the Chicago Teachers Union said 73% of its members endorsed the action.
Public health commissioner Dr. Allison Arwady held a news conference on Tuesday to scotch claims that chidden were in danger by being at school.
‘One of the things I’m hearing the most misinformation about is that Chicago hospitals are filling up with children, that many Chicago children are dying of COVID,’ Arwady said.
‘That is being driven by unvaccinated adults. Child COVID hospitalizations remain very rare.
‘Across the whole city, approximately 550,000 children, we are averaging just seven COVID hospitalizations a day right now for children aged zero to 17.
‘If you’re vaccinated, if you’re child is vaccinated, this is behaving like the flu and we don’t close school districts, especially for extended periods of time, for the flu.’
Lightfoot said: ‘If we pause, what do we say to those parents who can’t afford to hire somebody to come in and watch their kids, who can’t ship their kids off to some other place, what do we say to those students who are already struggling?’
‘We need to lean in to the science and the data and not push that to the side and give in to fear-mongering and hysteria,’ she insisted.
The mayor also said she feared the delayed reopening would stretch on past the January 18 date planned by CTU leaders.
The CTU demanded that students and staff members provided a negative COVID-19 test result before entering buildings on Monday.
The union also wants daily health questionnaires to be reinstated, free masks for all staff and students and wants schools to shift to remote learning if 20% or more of staff is in isolation or quarantine.
The head of Chicago Public Schools, Pedro Martinez, is distributing 200,000 KN95 masks for teachers and staff, requiring indoor mask-wearing in schools and weekly testing is mandatory for unvaccinated staff members and optional for students.
Martinez has bent over backwards to meet the union’s demands.
The mayor said that CTU Sharkey denied Martinez’s request to delay the vote in order to allow officials to present an updated safety plan for returning in person.
‘The worst thing we can do is to shut the entire system down. What we need to be focused on is working together,’ Lightfoot said.
‘What I’d love to see CTU do is not force an illegal work stoppage. What I’d love to see them do is work hand-in-glove with us to get kids and their families vaccinated.’
Martinez has proposed that a school would move to virtual instruction if at least 40% of its classroom teachers are absent for two consecutive days due to COVID and schools would resume in-person instruction after five to 10 school days.
He is also restoring health screeners and temperature checks to allow entry into buildings.
However, these measures were insufficient for the teachers’ union and they voted to stay at home.
‘This decision was made with a heavy heart and a singular focus on student and community safety,’ the union said in a statement.
However, district officials blamed the union for the late cancellation, saying despite safety measures, including a high teacher vaccination rate, ‘our teachers are not willing to report to work.’
‘We are deeply concerned about this decision but even more concerned about its impact on the health, safety, and well-being of our students and families,’ the district said in a statement.