Niagara County Court Judge Matthew J. Murphy III told Christopher Belter, 20, (pictured) – who previously pleaded guilty to felony charges of rape and of sexual abuse in 2019 – on Tuesday that prison time would be ‘inappropriate’
Stunned victims and onlookers broke down in tears, with some even vomiting, when a 20-year-old New York State man who pleaded guilty to raping four teenage girls in his parents’ home was sentenced to just eight years probation by an elderly judge set to retire next month, for his heinous crimes.
The case is even more shocking because convicted Christopher Belter’s parents are facing charges they groomed their son’s victims by plying them with alcohol and marijuana.
Niagara County Court Judge Matthew J. Murphy III, 69, told Belter on Tuesday that prison time would be ‘inappropriate’ and instead ordered him to register as a sex offender instead.
Belter had pleaded guilty to felony charges including third-degree rape and attempted first-degree sexual abuse, and two misdemeanor charges of second-degree sexual abuse.
But the Niagara County judge decided against a prison sentence. Belter could have been facing up to eight years in prison for his crimes.
He assaulted his four victims between February 2017 and August 2018, with three aged 16 and one aged 15 at the time of the assaults at his family’s ‘party house’ in a wealthy Lewiston neighborhood, just a few miles from Niagara Falls.
State police claim that Belter’s mother Tricia Vacanti, 50 – a real estate lawyer – his stepfather Gary Sullo, 56, and a family friend Jessica M. Long, 42, allegedly groomed the four victims by supplying alcohol and marijuana.
One of Belter’s victims was heard crying as the judge read out his verdict, while Steven Cohen, representing one of the victims, told DailyMail.com that his client threw up after the decision.
Christopher Belter (center in black face mask) had pleaded guilty to felony charges including third-degree rape and attempted first-degree sexual abuse, and two misdemeanor charges of second-degree sexual abuse
Belter’s mother Tricia Vacanti, 50, stepfather Gary Sullo, 56, face 30 criminal counts in connection to the alcohol and drug-fueled parties at their home
Belter is seen being led into the court room ahead of his sentencing. One of Belter’s victims was heard crying as the judge read out his verdict, while Steven Cohen, representing another of the victims, reportedly said his client threw up after the decision
Belter assaulted his four victims between February 2017 and August 2018, with three aged 16 and one aged 15 at the time of the assaults at his family’s ‘party house’ in a wealthy Lewiston neighborhood, just a few miles from Niagara Falls
Judge Murphy told Belter that his eight-year probation would ‘be like a sword hanging over your head for the next eight years’.
‘I agonized — I’m not ashamed to say that I actually prayed over what is the appropriate sentence in this case, because there was great pain. There was great harm. There were multiple crimes committed in the case,’ said Judge Murphy to the shocked court room.
‘It seems to me that a sentence that involves incarceration or partial incarceration isn’t appropriate, so I am going to sentence you to probation.’
Judge Murphy did not offer any further explanation for his decision not impose jail time on Belter.
Only overseeing criminal cases in Niagra County since 2016, Murphy has not ruled on cases of this magnitude in the past.
He currently works as a judge for the County and Surrogate’s courts in Niagara County, New York, having been elected to the role in 2007.
In addition, Murphy serves as a part-time State Supreme Court justice, handling part of the county’s civil litigation calendar.
He also handles cases involving wills and estates, as well as Niagra county’s pistol permit hearings.
He was later re-elected in 2017 as a judge for the Niagra County Court system, after running for the position unopposed.
Due to his advanced age, Murphy will only be able to serve a few more weeks as an elected judge, before he reaches New York State’s mandatory judicial retirement age of 70 next month.
Prosecutors do not have the ability to appeal his decision.
When giving his verdict on Tuesday, Judge Murphy (pictured) said he ‘agonized’ over the case before deciding to hand Belter eight years of probation
Before receiving his sentence, Belter (pictured in court) said that he felt ‘deep shame and regret’ for his actions
Belter told the court: ‘I hope each of you could close that wound I gashed. I know, though, that a scar will remain that will serve as a reminder of the evil of that night’
Cohen, Litigation Chair at Amherst-based legal firm HoganWillig, PLLC, revealed to DailyMail.com Thursday that his client threw up after the contentious decision.
Family friend Jessica M. Long, 42, has pleaded not guilty to charges of child endangerment and unlawfully dealing with a child
‘If Chris Belter was not a white defendant from a rich and influential family, it is my belief… he would surely have been sentenced to prison,’ Cohen said.
‘The greater harm however,’ the attorney added, ‘is that the sentencing in this matter would seem to perpetuate the insane belief that rape is not a serious crime and that its occurrence results in little consequence to the perpetrator.
‘Our society needs to do much better.’
Moreover, Belter’s mother Tricia Vacanti, 50, stepfather Gary Sullo, 56, and a family friend Jessica M. Long, 42, have all pleaded not guilty to charges of child endangerment and unlawfully dealing with a child.
Vacanti allegedly smoked marijuana with the teenage victims and supplied them with jello shots.
She, along with Sullo face 30 criminal counts in connection to the alcohol and drug-fueld parties at their home. Long faces single counts on her charges.
The three adults are still due to go on trial.
Belter’s mother Tricia Vacanti, 50, stepfather Gary Sullo, 56, face 30 criminal counts in connection to the alcohol and drug-fueld parties at their home. They also face 22 counts of child endangerment and unlawfully dealing with a child. Both have pleaded not guilty
Belter assaulted his four victims between February 2017 and August 2018, with three aged 16 and one aged 15 at the time of the assaults, at his family’s ‘party house’ (pictured) in a wealthy Lewiston neighborhood
At the time of his plea, Belter was placed on two years’ interim probation by Judge Sarah Sheldon – who has since retired – which allowed him the opportunity to apply for youth offender status.
This would have lessened any potential prison sentence he could have received and prevented him from having to register on the sex offender’s list.
However, Belter revealed in court last month that he broke the terms of this interim probation by installing software on his computer to watch pornography.
During the case, the fourth victim gave a statement describing the assault on her, commenting on which Judge Murphy said: ‘He told her to stop being such a baby… The Defendant told her that, if she stopped resisting, it wouldn’t hurt as much.’
Prior to sentencing, WKBW reports that Belter addressed the courtroom to reveal his ‘deep shame and regret’ for his actions.
He said: ‘I hope each of you could close that wound I gashed. I know, though, that a scar will remain that will serve as a reminder of the evil of that night.’
Belter will appear in court again on December 3 so that a ruling can be made on what level of sex offender he will be classified as.
Vacanti, a lawyer, allegedly smoked marijuana with the teenage victims and supplied them with jello shots. She, along with Sullo face 30 criminal counts in connection to the alcohol and drug-fueld parties at their home. Long faces single counts on her charges