New York Giants Mailbag: Memories, Nate Solder, and Playing Tag

New York Giants Mailbag: Memories, Nate Solder, and Playing Tag

If you would love to send a concern for our viewers mailbag, please send it to [email protected].

What’s up, Joseph? So the means the franchise business tag functions is if a gamer was marked when in the past, if he obtains marked once again, his tag quantity is whatever the forecasted tag is or 120% of what he gained the previous year, whichever was greater.

So in Leonard Williams’ situation, if he’s franchised, his quantity due would not be decreased offered the decrease in the income cap; instead, he would certainly be owed a 20% raising on what he gained in 2015.

Hey Brian, I wish you’re maintaining cozy and risk-free. All has actually been peaceful on the Solder front, yet my sixth sense is both sides component means.

If he returns, I do not recognize exactly how useful a relocate to right take on would certainly be considering that he hasn’t played the setting considering that his newbie period. If I’m the Giants, I want to go more youthful at that area if Matt Peart isn’t my solution.

As for Solder’s prospective cap hit, take a look at this write-up, as I do not see why the Giants and Solder can not participate in a comparable setup as what the Saints and Drew Brees participated in.

From Rafael G.

I am asking yourself why nobody has actually provided the recommendations that the Giants needs to offer Leonard Williams the shift tag as opposed to the franchise business tag. What are your ideas and why isn’t this suggestion provided More Often by various other authors?

Hi Rafael Last year I was banging the drum for the Giants to use the shift tag on Williams due to the fact that the Giants remained in a little various situation than they are this year. But after the year he had, I believe positioning the shift tag on him is welcoming one more group with cap area to find swooshing in and scoop him up, leaving the Giants without any opportunity of matching.

The various other point is it’s not an excellent suggestion to allow the marketplace established the asking cost. If you can obtain a watermelon for 50 cents per extra pound from the neighborhood farmer’s market, and after that some abundant individual occurs and provides $1.00 per extra pound, you simply lost on what you most likely assumed was a reasonable market value.

You are likewise thinking that the Giants would certainly obtain a comp choice if they utilized the shift tag if they shedWilliams Again, that’s not established in rock. What occurs if the Giants indicator a lot more gamers than they shed or authorize a big-money receiver that negates the Williams deal?

No, in this situation, you utilize the franchise business tag, and you really hope that you can pertain to a new long-lasting offer that reduces that initial year’s cap hit. (I will certainly have a recommended agreement that does simply that online later on today.)

From Matt L.

The 18 Feb 2021 podcast was definitely unpleasant– like you do not recognize! What a fantastic recall at our fabled Giants background! Thanks for the recall at some fantastic memories!

Thanks Matt That podcast style was in fact recommended by an audience so I figured it’s finest to obtain it off the beaten track.

I do not recognize if it appeared in my voice, yet a couple of times I needed to quit videotaping to compose myself in remembering several of those intestine strikes. Anyway, offered the topic, I’m grateful you delighted in the podcast.

From Jon H.

The Giants are mosting likely to require a swing take on and are mosting likely to owe Nate Solder at the very least $6.5 million whatever. If he’s video game, is it feasible they authorize him to a reorganized offer for around $6.5 and hefty with rewards?

Hi Jon I touched a little bit previously on this subject in the mailbag, yet once again, I would certainly be stunned if the Giants roll with Nate Solder at right take on. I recognize in 2015 I had actually suggested he pay right take on and Thomas play left, yet after that I withdrawed that after a couple of offending line experts clarified why that would not be a sensible relocation.

And anyhow, I’m not encouraged he also needs to find back, though to be clear, nobody has actually claimed anything main. People appear to believe it’s very easy to other side on the offending line– it’s not. And if I’m the Giants, I make it an indicate obtain more youthful on that particular team, preferably.

From Jordan U.

I think you would certainly call me a veteran audience, very first time emailer. I delight in paying attention to your podcasts, and I simply had the ability to pay attention to last Thursday’s journey down memory lane concerning finest Giants success … a number of my preferred success are consolidated some individual memories too. I wish you’ll allow me “wax” a little bit:

First, that Week 11 video game in 1986, which you discussed actually protrudes in my mind too. Back in those days, my papa videotaped each video game to send out to my uncle that resided in Ohio and could not obtain the video games … he had actually simply returned from a journey with my mother and really did not see the video game live, yet among the initial points he did was pop that tape in and view it with me.

Right prior to fourth and 17, he had actually transformed it off, assuming that the video game mored than. I’d currently seen it, and I keep in mind yelling, “Wait! Dad! Don’t turn it off!” I likewise remember this being the video game where we assumed that this group was mosting likely to be something unique.

Here are a few other significant non-playoff success:

  • 2011, Week 17 – This was the “win-or-go-home” video game versus theCowboys Winner wins the department, loser goes house. I was fortunate adequate to be at this video game, and I keep in mind the electrical power in the group boggled the mind. When Cruz had that very early 74-yard TD, I do not ever before remember it being that loud in MetLife. He likewise had that dive round catch later on in the video game that almost secured it for theGiants
  • 2011, Week 3 – This was Victor Cruz’s “coming out game,” where he had the lengthy TD, and after that one more one later on in the video game. This video game was specifically enjoyable due to the fact that the Eagles this year had actually set up that so-called “Dream Team,” and it’s constantly wonderful to argue theEagles I likewise was lucky adequate to be in the mean this too. My recollection of Eagles’ followers is not totally unfavorable – they are equally as tough on their group as they get on the opposing one. I bear in mind that late in the video game, ex-spouse-Giants receiver Steve Smith that was currently betting the Eagles had a pass jump off his hands for an INT. The Eagles follower resting alongside me began yelling “Double agent! He’s a double agent!” I had an excellent poke fun at that a person.

And another “under-the-radar” one:

  • 1998, Week 15 – The Giants were going no place this period and the unbeaten Broncos were involving community. I keep in mind paying attention to this video game on the radio as I was driving house from university. The video game was being available in and out of fixed, and I had the ability to listen to simply sufficient to ask yourself exactly how the Giants were maintaining it so close. I made it home in the nick of time to see Kent Graham get in touch with Amani Toomer on the permission TD with a min left. In a period where very little went right, it was still quite pleasing to see the G-Men send out the champs packaging.

Anyway, I wager I could think of a great deal a lot more … yet you recognize what’s amusing? As long as the success, I likewise keep in mind those gut-punch losses. I wager you can fill up a number of podcasts up with those too. Anyway, I’m anticipating the web content you’ll have for us as we expect the draft! Keep up the magnum opus and as constantly, Go Giants!

Pat Says: Thanks for sharing your memories, Jordan–and many thanks to you I was motivated to do the “gut punch” episode this previous week. That one was a difficult tablet to ingest, so pay attention at your very own threat.

And yes, I remember your 3 preferred memories. I covered all 3 of them and remember them well since you stated them.

From Donald S.

I think Kevin Zeitler is a strong Guard yet is paid too much; I think he will certainly make $12 million. Why do the Giants need to pick in between maintaining him at that income or reducing him? If as a matter of fact Zeitler recognizes the marketplace and understands that as a freelance he will not obtain a $12 million buck deal, can not the Giants and Zeitler make a new offer that maintains him on the group for much less cash? The Giants require a strong O-lineman and Zeitler will certainly require an agreement if the Giants are not ready to pay him $12 million.

Thanks for the inquiry,Donald I intend the Giants could come close to Kevin Zeitler concerning a pay cut, yet on what premises do they validate it? He was their finest offending electrician in 2015, right? So generally, you do not ask individuals that carried out to take a pay cut.

That claimed, I maintain returning and forth on this. I desire the Giants to maintain Zeitler yet not expand his offer and the capacity for dead cash to decrease the cap number.

I believe the Giants will certainly rather want to expand James Bradberry and/ or Blake Martinez, both of whom played well, and 2 calls where it makes even more feeling to restructure/extend than it does Zeitler’s offer.


What’s next for the Giants this off-season? Sign up for our FREE e-newsletter for all the current, and make certain to adhere to and like us onFacebook Submit your concerns for our mailbag And do not neglect to take a look at the everyday LockedOn Giants podcast, likewise offered for registration any place you locate podcasts.