European Commission proposes UK data adequacy agreement

European Commission proposes UK data adequacy agreement

The magazine of 2 draft data adequacy choices brings the UK closer to a last favorable choice, which will certainly make it possible for the ongoing complimentary circulation of data in between the EU and also the UK if green-lit by participant states

Sebastian  Klovig Skelton


  • Sebastian Klovig Skelton,.
    Senior press reporter

Published: 19 Feb 2021 17:30

The European Commission (EC) has actually shown its readiness to provide a data adequacy agreement for the UK, based on official authorization by EU participant states.

The commission has actually released 2 draft data adequacy choices, one under the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and also an additional under the Law Enforcement Directive (LED), to enable the proceeded transfer of individual data to the UK, propelling the procedure of their official fostering

The objective of data adequacy choices is to identify whether a nation, or industry within a nation, outside the European Union (EU) has basically equal data security requirements to the bloc and also as a result whether data can be shown it.

The UK has actually currently established under its very own policies that the EU provides a sufficient degree of data security, with the draft choices currently looking for to evaluate whether data is still able to stream in the various other instructions from the EU to the UK complying with Brexit.

According to the choices, the EC takes into consideration that the UK’s data security regulations “ensure a level of protection for personal data… that is essentially equivalent” under both the GDPR and also LED, which the “oversight mechanisms and redress avenues” are completely solid sufficient to permit data based on exercise their civil liberties and also permission violations.

Both draft choices will certainly currently be scrutinised by the European Data Protection Board (EDPB) yet, since the board itself does not have power to obstruct the choices, they will certainly likewise require sign-off from EU participant states prior to they can be totally embraced by the EC.

Data is presently able to stream from the EU to the UK under the Trade and also Cooperation Agreement joined 24 December 2020, which gives a six-month connecting duration to permit the ongoing circulation of data while the adequacy choices are totally evaluated.

“A flow of secure data between the EU and the UK is crucial to maintain close trade ties and cooperate effectively in the fight against crime. Today we launch the process to achieve that. We have thoroughly checked the privacy system that applies in the UK after it has left the EU,” claimed Commissioner for Justice Didier Reynders.

“Now European data protection authorities will thoroughly examine the draft texts. EU citizens’ fundamental right to data protection must never be compromised when personal data travels across the Channel. The adequacy decisions, once adopted, would ensure just that.”

If the participant states concur the UK suffices under the LED, it will certainly note the very first time such an adequacy choice has actually been made under the instruction, with many police data transfers from the EU presently regulated by global arrangements that do not consider the criterion of necessary equivalence that currently exists.

Twelve adequacy choices have actually been made under the GDPR because it entered into impact in May 2018, with Andorra, Argentina, Canada, the Faroe Islands, Guernsey, Israel, the Isle of Man, Japan, Jersey, New Zealand, Switzerland and also Uruguay all being acknowledged as ample territories by the EC.

In July 2020, the Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU) overruled the EU-US Privacy Shield data- sharing agreement for stopping working to guarantee that European residents had ample civil liberties of remedy when data can be gathered by the United States National Security Agency (NSA) and also various other United States knowledge solutions.

The judgment, informally referred to as Schrems II after the Austrian legal representative that took the situation to the CJEU, discovered that individuals should be provided “essentially equivalent protection” for their data when it is moved to the United States and also various other nations as they would certainly obtain in the EU under the GDPR and also the European Charter of Fundamental Rights, which ensures individuals the right for personal interactions and also the security of their personaldata The standing of EU-US data adequacy has still yet to be totally solved.

Even though both adequacy choices for the UK purpose to attain the exact same criterion of necessary equivalence, policies for the security of individual data vary in between the GDPR and also LED, with the last laying out sector-specific policies to control just how individual data can be refined and also moved by criminal justice organisations for police objectives.

The official fostering of one adequacy choice as a result does not involve the automated fostering of the various other, as both require to be evaluated individually by themselves values.

UK federal government and also technology industry respond to GDPR adequacy

Secretary of state for electronic Oliver Dowden invited the magazine of the draft choices, which he asserted mirror the UK’s dedication to high data security requirements.

“Although the EU’s progress in this area has been slower than we would have wished, I am glad we have now reached this significant milestone following months of constructive talks in which we have set out our robust data protection framework,” he claimed.

“I now urge the EU to fulfil their commitment to complete the technical approval process promptly, so businesses and organisations on both sides can seize the clear benefits.”

The draft choices have actually likewise been gotten favorably by sector bodies standing for a selection of services in the UK’s technology industry.

“Today’s decision is warmly welcomed by the tech sector which has been making clear the importance of a mutual data adequacy agreement since the day after the referendum,” claimed Julian David, Chief Executive Officer of TechUK.

“Receiving data adequacy, alongside the EU-UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement, will set a solid foundation for digital trade with the EU, including strong non-discrimination clauses and positive data flows provisions, that will give businesses the confidence to invest.”

Stephen Kelly, chair of Tech Nation, included the global transfer of data was essential to UK technology, especially for industries like economic modern technology (fintech) where fast development has actually been asserted on opening the worth of data.

“The data economy makes up about 4% of national GDP and is predicted to be worth $130bn by 2025, making the UK a global hub for data flows. The positive adequacy decision between the UK and the EU therefore brings great news to the tech sector, following months of waiting and contingency planning in the bridging period,” he claimed.

“It supports the continued growth of tech scaleups and the position of the UK as a global leader in data-driven technologies. As we look ahead at building back better, the international flow of data will be vital to fueling the next wave of business innovation and driving transformation in our society.”

Potential concerns with protecting LED adequacy

In very early February 2021, the EDPB released its very first advice on the LED, creating that “adequacy decisions should focus on the assessment of the existing legislation of the third country concerned as a whole, in theory and practice, in light of the assessment criteria set out in the LED.”

It included: “Any meaningful analysis of adequate protection must [therefore] comprise two basic elements: the content of the rules applicable and the means for ensuring their effective implementation in practice.”

While the EDPB was creating in the context of LED adequacy, the procedure of analysing UK data security regulations in both concept and also method likewise relates to GDPR adequacy.

Data security professionals have actually formerly advised that while the UK’s LED dedications exist theoretically with its transposition in Part Three of the Data Protection Act (DPA 18)– which is proven by the EC draft choice– specific techniques within the UK’s knowledge solutions and also criminal justice industry (CJS) can weaken the nation’s capability to safeguard a favorable adequacy choice under the instruction.

These problems likewise include GDPR adequacy, yet more stringent policies on just how data can be moved for police objectives suggest they are especially troublesome for LED adequacy.

Specifically, they mentioned the close partnership in between the UK and also the United States as an issue as a result of the latter’s absence of ample data security requirements, along with the UK’s very own invasive security routine, which has actually been preserved in the Investigatory Powers Act 2016, or else referred to as the “Snoopers’ Charter”.

The expanding use US-based public cloud solutions by UK authorities and also the larger CJS was likewise mentioned as a possibly substantial issue for the UK’s capability to acquire LED adequacy due to the possibility for remote accessibility to that data and also its forward move to a non-adequate territory.

While the draft choices are big, 50-plus web page papers that need thorough evaluation to totally recognize, impressions from police experts revealed dissatisfaction that the EC paper is mostly a lawful recap and also does not appear to take into consideration these sensible, real-world elements.

They likewise recommended that while this EC adequacy referral has actually been released it is still prematurely to think it will certainly pass.

“The LED is not a single EU-wide regulation like the GDPR” claimed Owen Sayers, a UK- based independent personal privacy specialist with substantial understanding of the LED. “Each EU member state, including the UK when we were EU members, has created its own interpretation of the directive, and the EC recently published a study of the multiple different implementations across the EU demonstrating how much they vary country to country.”

Sayers included “Each participant state will possibly intend to examine the EC referral to guarantee its searchings for straighten with their very own regulation. In impact the UK requires 27 favorable lawful evaluations of LED positioning to be efficiently passed as ample, whereas GDPR requires just one.

“Even then it is not yet clear how much data the EU member states will be willing to share – an adequacy finding enables data sharing but it does not oblige a member to do so.”

Content Continues Below

Read extra on Privacy and also data security

  • Assessing UK police data adequacy

    By: SebastianKlovig Skelton

  • Brexit offer gives UK short-lived data adequacy

    By: SebastianKlovig Skelton

  • Negotiating the intricacies of global transfers of individual data

    By: Leonie Power

  • Forrester: CIOs should plan for Brexit data transfer

    By: Cliff Saran