Euthanasia: Dutch court expands law on dementia cases

File pic of syringeImage copyright
Getty Images

Image caption

The ruling comes after a doctor was acquitted last year of any wrongdoing in a euthanasia trial

Doctors in the Netherlands can no longer be prosecuted for carrying out euthanasia on dementia patients who have previously given written consent.

Previously, patients would need to confirm their request.

But on Tuesday the Dutch Supreme Court ruled this was no longer the case.

The decision comes after a doctor was taken to court for carrying out assisted suicide on a patient with Alzheimer’s, who had previously asked for the procedure in a statement.

Prosecutors said the doctor did not properly consult the unnamed 74-year-old. But the family supported the doctor’s decision, and she was acquitted of any wrongdoing last year.

  • Belgian doctors cleared in first euthanasia trial
  • Germany overturns ban on assisted suicide

It is a landmark decision in the Netherlands. The country became the first in the world to legalise euthanasia in 2002, albeit under strict conditions.

These include that the patients must be enduring “unbearable and endless suffering”, and that at least two doctors agree to the procedure.

If these conditions are met, doctors “may carry out a written request beforehand for euthanasia in people with advanced dementia,” the court ruled on Tuesday.

Patients must also have made this request before their dementia was so advanced that they could “no long express their will”.

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionDaughter calls for change in laws on assisted dying

The decision stems from a court case involving a 64-year-old doctor who carried out the assisted suicide in 2016.

After being diagnosed with Alzheimer’s four years before she died, the unnamed patient wrote a statement saying that she wanted to be euthanised before entering a care home, but adding that she wanted to decide “while still in my senses and when I think the time is right”.

  • Portugal MPs in move to legalise euthanasia
  • Assisted dying law ‘totally lacks compassion’

Before she was taken into care, a doctor decided that assisted suicide should be administered based on her prior statement. This was confirmed by two separate doctors independently.

When the day came to end the woman’s life, a sedative was put in her coffee and she lost consciousness.

But the woman then woke up and had to be held down by her daughter and husband while the process was finished.

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionBill Bryson: How do we deal with ageing?
source: bbc.com