Manchester United
David de Gea
His most dire display for United? The Spaniard was culpable for both of the City goals. 2/10
Ashley Young
Responded to recent criticism with a compact display in a solid rearguard (De Gea apart). 5
Matteo Darmian
First league start under Solskjær and he was accomplished enough to vindicate selection. 6
Chris Smalling
Had a near-nightmare moment, nearly deflecting a shot into his own goal – but De Gea saved. 6
Victor Lindelöf
Was rarely troubled by City’s attackers in what was a smooth display from United’s best centre‑back. 7
Luke Shaw
Pace was a threat on his return from three‑game ban but he faded after the break. Booked. 6
Paul Pogba
Would he bring his A-game? This was the good Pogba who always looked to be positive. 7
Fred
Composed and classy, and did all of the running expected of a holding midfielder. 7
Andreas Pereira
Was cultured in arguably his best display in United colours – unlucky to be replaced. Booked. 7
Marcus Rashford
Troubled Kompany and Laporte at times but will be frustrated at not capitalising on his ascendancy. 7
Jesse Lingard
Harried and hassled defenders but missed two golden chances to score, the second an open goal. 5
Subs: Romelu Lukaku (for Pereira, 72) 6; Anthony Martial (for Lingard, 83) 5; Alexis Sánchez (for Darmian, 83) 5.
Manchester City
Ederson
Passing not always precise but made one superb interception from Lingard’s ball to deny Rashford. 7/10
Kyle Walker
Hit one pass straight out, was shaky and failed to join the attack enough to aid his team. 4
Vincent Kompany
Booked inside 10 minutes in what was a torrid evening in 18th league outing in a derby. Booked. 5
Aymeric Laporte
Like Kompany, he could not handle Rashford early on in one of his poorer displays this term. 5
Oleksandr Zinchenko
Struggled with the pace and when booked put himself under pressure. Booked. 5
Fernandinho
Was the pick of City’s midfielders until he had to limp off early in second half after tackle on Pogba. 7
David Silva
Could have been sent off for a boot in Pereira’s chest but was also a telling influence. 7
Ilkay Gündogan
Was initially unable to control the midfield for City but became more of a factor as the game went on. 7
Bernardo Silva
Like his team, got better as the contest progressed and scored a fine goal to break the deadlock. 8
Sergio Agüero
Given little service up front but was still sharp and difficult for the home team to contain. 7
Raheem Sterling
Should have scored opener as the interval neared but was instrumental in City’s second strike. 7
Subs: Leroy Sané (for Fernandinho, 51) 7; Jesus (for Agüero, 89) 6, Danilo (for Gündogan, 89) 6.