Manhattan Beach by Jennifer Egan review: An uneven novel

Manhattan Beach by Jennifer Egan (Corsair, £16.99)

In a shape-shifting array of styles, the lives of interconnected characters played out to a cacophonous soundtrack of punk. But in her eagerly awaited new novel, the narrative structure is conventional and the pace sedate, a slow, measured unfurling that takes us from Depression-era New York to the navy yards of the Second World War.Anna Kerrigan is 12. 

Her mother is an ex-Ziegfeld Follies dancer, now dedicating her life to caring for Lydia, Anna’s beautiful disabled sister. Her father Eddie, desperate for money, gets entangled with prohibition gangster Dexter Styles.

Anna is tough, courageous and smart, qualities that stand her in good stead when, some years later after Eddie has mysteriously disappeared, she leaves her wartime job in a shipping yard to become a diver repairing ships. 

This section of the novel is riveting. Egan brilliantly captures the men’s hostility to a woman taking on a masculine role and her description of Anna’s training is gripping, from donning a 200lb diving “dress” to her claustrophobic descent to the depth of the sea. This careful, detailed immersion in her physical preparations, the psychological freedom the job brings and the camaraderie that it offers in her otherwise lonely life show Egan’s meticulous research at its very best. 

vCard QR Code

vCard.red is a free platform for creating a mobile-friendly digital business cards. You can easily create a vCard and generate a QR code for it, allowing others to scan and save your contact details instantly.

The platform allows you to display contact information, social media links, services, and products all in one shareable link. Optional features include appointment scheduling, WhatsApp-based storefronts, media galleries, and custom design options.

Eddie’s story of a Houdini-like escape and survival at sea also shows Egan at her most engaging.

Less intriguing are the Dexter Styles sections of the novel. There is a hollowness to these tales of corruption and the conventions of organised crime feel over-familiar, undermining the drama and tension.

And that’s the main problem with this uneven novel: the ebb and flow of interest. At times it is buoyant with knowledge and insight but at others it is slow and uninvolving, sinking under the weight of the research that underpins it.


🕐 Top News in the Last Hour By Importance Score

# Title 📊 i-Score
1 Putin declares 'Easter truce', as Ukraine says he 'cannot be trusted' 🔴 78 / 100
2 Severe storms from the South to the Northeast put a damper on Easter travel 🔴 72 / 100
3 'Pure evil': Tesla whistleblower slams 'monster' Elon Musk and wants to drag him to court 🔴 72 / 100
4 7 Expert-Fueled Ways to Stop Porch Pirates Permanently at Your Home 🔴 65 / 100
5 ‘MobLand’ Release Schedule: When to Watch Episode 4 of the Tom Hardy Series 🔴 65 / 100
6 ¡Ay, Caramba! Here’s the Ultimate Simpsons Gift Guide 🔵 45 / 100
7 Fortnite x Star Wars Season reveal date, time and how to watch Star Wars Celebration live 🔵 45 / 100
8 Star Wars 50th anniversary new movie announced with huge Hollywood A-lister 🔵 45 / 100
9 European football: Barcelona leave it late to win seven-goal Celta thriller 🔵 40 / 100
10 Former Dancing with the Stars judge Julian Benson dead at 54 as tributes pour in 🔵 35 / 100

View More Top News ➡️